ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums - Did the right person go tonight?

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)

- The X Factor 2012 [S9] (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=602)

- - Did the right person go tonight? (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=215004)

Yes and no, I'm not really bothered. Just a bit gutted there wasn't as much drama as last time.

I was hoping they'd go to Louis last again so he could drag it out for another ten minutes only to take it to Deadlock as Gary knocks him out and Dermot explodes with rage.

Quote:

Originally Posted by kazanne (Post 5589126)

WHY?:conf:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Apple202 (Post 5589134)

Because they deserve it, for getting rid of the talent week by week in favour of ****ty boybands and Rylan, and also there mission to make this series a cock fest with only Ella remaining.

Out of the Bottom 2? Yes otherwise it should have been Chris or D3.

Rylan is flawless and Kye could cure insomnia and has no chance of selling records.

YES

I have voted yes, not because I don't like Kye who I actually thought was the best on X Factor on Saturday night but because the public vote was used to decide who went, if the public chose him to go then for me that is the right decision.

The sing off was good for both acts and maybe if contestants chose their own songs and the way they sang them, then perhaps their individual X factors could shine though more.
As it is, the public have not warmed to Kye at all, they clearly haven't been impressed by the song choices he has been made to sing and for that Gary is to blame totally.

I believe when the public are spending money to save acts then they should decide who goes, deadlock is the only way to get that result.
Kye got the least votes,that is a clear fact, we had all this with Katie being saved week after week by the judges, not allowing it to go to deadlock when a lot of us wished it had been so.

I felt sorry for Kye but he had a really bad mentor,borne out by the fact in 5 weeks he has lost all 3 of the acts he chose to put through to the live finals.

Yeah, the boy bands are awful.

Yes because it was hilarious to see Gary go into meltdown
and Kye would never have won anyway, too boring..

Carolynne, MK1 and Jade shouldn't have gone though

Yeah. Kye wasn't going to go far, certainly wasn't going to be a successful popstar. Rylan's gonna get through next week before graciously bowing out to whichever boy band is still there, and then they'll be out before the final.

Jahmene, James, Ella = final three
Union J = fourth
Christopher = fifth
Rylan = sixth
District 3 = seventh