Originally Posted by the_answers (Post 6365239)

Sorry it's not the questioners fault if you have struggle to answer a simple enough question.
You're free to elaborate and give your reasons as I guess you've done.


Each to their own.
I just don't think sympathy alone is enough reason to be crowned winner. (not that I'm saying that's your only reason)
Just personally I avoid the outside world and their backgrounds and look what they're doing in there.

Originally Posted by the_answers (Post 6365276)

A basic question can't be rude and to object to it being "simplistic" just seems silly.

We've all got our own ideas what warrants a worthy winner.

But IMO you only have to look at Sam and Luke to see how outside influences affected the final outcome.

Originally Posted by the_answers (Post 6365169)

Carol's character is a bit vile but that doesn't mean she or her fans are.

I simply don't like her as a HM because I don't think she's particularly entertaining playing the bitch (and she's getting all the help and attention too).