She may have servants, but I'm sure she doesn't try to humiliate them, as Jackiey tried to do. I'm sure Shilpas' servants are more like friends to her, i don't imagine she's tries to degrade them. She has respect. From what I've seen of her in the house so far, she seems a very genuine person, with no alterior motives. After watching the altercation with Jackiey and Shilpa, I think it's pretty obvious that Jackiey took it to the nextlevel, Shilpa was just trying to have a civilised conversation with her, but Jackiey went on the defence straight away and became aggressive.

Shilpa isn't putting on a show in my opinion, she's being real. :thumbs:

I'm not mad about Shilpa, but I don't think she did anything wrong at all in this instance. In fact, I think she showed great self restraint. Jackiey was humiliating Leo - and enjoying it too. Shilpa didn't feel comfortable with that, and she tried to tell Jackiey that in a diplomatic manner. Unfortunately, she credited Jackiey with too much intelligence; Jackiey has neither the brains nor the diplomacy to understand what Shilpa was saying. In fact, Jackiey didn't even want to try to understand. Even Jade was embarrassed by her mother's behaviour! BB has made a huge mistake putting that family in.

Oh nooo! Shilpa gave an old man a blanket to keep him warm, she's sooo evil, lets get her out of that house, that's shocking! :bigsmile:

Why is that sly, she was being nice and considerate! Doesn't make her a bad person now does it!?

Exactly man, don't understand people.:puzzled:

i agree wit some of ur points, and im a shilpa fanatic, so dont worry i wont storm on u :p..

however i still want her to win :D x

Some people always seem to assume there is a hidden agenda behind people's actions :rolleyes:

Jackieys intentions was to have a laugh from what I saw and to live it up while she could...its not going to be often when she will have servants so she was making the most of it.

I personally think that Shilpa found the whole "servants" as an attack on how she lives and she wanted people to know she doesn't treat her servants like that back at home. I think it really hit home with her more than anyone else because we all know that Shilpa has said she has two maids, a hairdresser etc. Even though Jackiey has an aggresive tone to the way she speaks I don't think she set out to start a fight...sheerly because she isn't smart enough.

In the law, ignorance is not an excuse!:wink:

I honestly saw it as though Jackiey was humiliating the 'servants', and Shilpa didn't like that. In Shilpa's normal lifestyle it is not unusual to have servants, but it does not mean that she would necessarily humiliate them. Jackiey has always struck me as aggressive and petty. Even Jade was ashamed of her mother's behaviour.

I think theres some truth in that. Im sure Shilpa was telling the truth when she claimed that she treats her servants well, but there could have been feelings of guilt or just a sense that the task was directed at her and her lifestyle. I think shes been defensive during the whole thing.

Its only ignorant if she continues to mock the servants. From what I saw she was just having fun. None of the servants seemed to have issues with it so why did Shilpa see it as her fight.... If Leo has issues with it he would of said no but from what I remember he was "playing along". Its only a game and living it up while they can was part of the game. Taking such offense to such a small thing made me think the issues are with Shilpa and deeper than it looks on the surface.

We also have to remember that Shilpa & Jermaine made judgements on Jackiey in the showerroom where they think we cannot see or hear. Her voice was mentioned alone and that was only on the first night and Jermaine was talking about leaving already. I don't think one set of people are to blame personally I think its a bit on both sides. I am not at all a big Jade fan or her family but I think both sets of people could have done more to get to know each other personally. Maybe then Shilpa would understand Jackiey was just having a joke around rather than being nasty.

I could be wrong but I thought that it was Jade that Shilpa and Jermaine were talking about. Either way, they were talking about how annoying her voice was. They didn't need to know her to decide that, they just had to listen to her.

I love shilpa, shes very downto earth and kind, she didnt want to make a scene. She seems to be one of the niceest housemates in there!
Shes no being sly, manipulative or whatever you want to call her!

Both of their voices are rather annoying but I am sure people who are not use to Shilpas could say the same. People shouldn't jugde others on just their voice though or form an opinion of them on that alone. The only person who was actually bothered to get to know them was Ken and even they admitted that.

The "manipulative" word is another good one which people on BBBM have said about Shilpa...I can see where they are coming from that tears can sometimes be used to manipulate but I don't see Shilpa as a manipulative person but she is a hypocrit.

They weren't judging her - they were just saying that she had an annoying voice. It's true, she does.

But someone having an annoying voice is rather a full on thing to leave a show for...had to be more to it than that.

they were both in the wrong.
but i think jackey is playing to the cameras whereas shilpa is far from doing that because she has no clue about BB as shes never seen it

Playing to the cameras or just trying to make a task fun? In the terms of the task I think she only had intentions of making it fun and living it up...Shilpa maybe took offense to that as thats her way of normal life which is so far apart from Jackieys.

jackiey mad herself look like a twat last nite

i am asian and in are culture it is to have respect for our olders and as u can see she called him uncle so i dont think it was for sympathy

get shilpa out

I do not trust that Shilpa she is like a Snake

OK so let me get this straight. Shilpa is the bad guy cos she did something nice? Righto.

LMAO Nono :joker: