2015 had Basketball Wives LA S4 so automatically wins.

CBB13 vs. CBB15 - easy call since 15 sucks and I will never get the love for it
S28 vs. S30 - duh
TAR24 vs. TAR26 - duh
BBCan2 vs. BBCan3 - duh
BBUK15 vs. BBUK16 - by the slimmest of margins since both are awful
BBUS16 vs. BBUS17 - duh
CBB14 vs. CBB16 - I think 14 gets way too much hate on here just for the record
S29 vs. S31 - duh, everyone knows how much I hated this season of Survivor
TAR25 vs. TAR27 - I like both seasons a good amount but 25 definitely benefits from being at the right time and at the right place

this was a pretty ****ty year for reality TV and writing this all out just confirmed that for me. So my official answer is 2014.

The winners were just too predictable this year don't you think Macie?

I think this years winners were better than last year and more unpredictable imo. The only unpredictable winner we got in 2014 was Helen winning BB15. This year we had Katie Price, Chloe, Vicky Pattison (to a smaller extent). As well as LI Jess <33