I voted for the 2014 Cheryl's crap decisions. Sending Steph Nala and Chloe Jasmine (sorry) over Lola Saunders and Kerianne Covell was a ****ing outrage. At least Lola got her shot though and did better than the other 2 who shouldn't have been picked (although I did like Chloe Jasmine and she could have been the wildcard).

Sophie Habibis went way too early, some bad song choices that didn't match her voice really messed with her votes. Her voice is probably one of my favourites from the show still

Emily and Keriann should have been put through instead, thankfully Emily is back now

To be fair there is something about Stephanie's voice I really liked when she was in the luminites but when she tried going solo it just didn't work for her

Cheryl usually makes bad decisions though on her live shows

Ellie & James
Carolynne

Laura being sent out was not a travesty, the public voted stupid that week. Ruth totally out sung her in the sing off and deserved to stay.

However everyone who got sent home over Chico was a travesty

Worst robbery's of each series (I watched):

Series 2 - Maria Lawson going home, especially when she did.
Series 3 - Nikitta going over Ray.
Series 4 - Uhm...
Series 5 - Diana going over Eoghan and JLS. Final 3 should have been Alex, Diana and Ruth.
Series 6 - Lucie going over Jedward, this was the moment I lost any respect in Simon's credibility.
Series 7 - TreyC going over Katie after Katie had just given up in the sing-off.
Series 8 - Janet being voted out based on her mistake in the live show and not on the actual sing-off.
Series 9 - Ella going as early as she did.
Series 10 - Melanie McCabe not making the live shows.
Series 11 - Lauren being eliminated in a stupid sing-off, the semi-final should be down to public votes alone.
Series 12 - 4th Impact and Lauren going home before Che and Reggie n Bollie.

Katie waisell not winning

Katie Waissel > Gamu, Cheryl made the right choice there.

In terms of the votes being a joke I'd say that Carolynne Poole being 13th out of 13 in week 1 was a joke when Jahmene, Rylan, and the two boybands were in the competition.

Katie Waissel being there fullstop was a joke, let alone when she started beating people like Aiden and Treyc.

And Jedward beating Lucie Jones when Simon had bashed them all series was also a joke, even though I actually liked Jedward.

Well I'd argue that Aiden and Paije had the best vocals that series.