Brian Freidman actually looks like a great judge now

Here for Robbie, but it should be Walsh and not that one

And mess @ the woman

Who actually signed this off and thought it was a good idea??

The thing is I don't have a problem with Robbie and Louis (though the panel should never have been changed in the first place), but sticking Robbie's wife on the panel just for the sake of it is all kinds of embarrassing

Should have been...
Simon Cowell
Louis Tomlinson
Nicole Scherzinger
Robbie Williams

Well I won't be watching.

The worst member of 1D (who thinks he's God's gift), a failed soap actress judging a music competition and old-timer Robbie.

No thanks.

This is embarrassing.

You always get the "lucky" member of a pop group, who rides on the coat tails of the others and has no talent whatsoever. Louis is that member.

As for Robbie Williams and wife. :laugh2:

Any tiny little semblance of credibility this show still had have just evaporated.

End it. End it now.

And we thought Nick Grimshaw was scraping the barrel. At least he had some kind of connection to the industry, no matter how arbitrary.

he had the connection to the industry, Ayda hasn't, she is irrelevant in the Judge panel LOL

imagine binning Nicole for a Loose Woman

What an appalling lineup.

Sharon sitting there drunkenly laughing at the **** ones would make a better panel. Bring back Penelope, Dawn, Krisztina, and Ant & Seb.

"Soz Nic, you're being axed for somebody from Loose Women"

Surely she must be seething? :laugh2:

They are all going to have to pretend they are thrilled too :joker:

Sorry but this is stupid. I would be willing to bet that Robbie said he wouldn't do it without Ayda though..and thats ho this has happened. But in that case, Simon should have let Robbie go and picked someone else tbh...

Edit. And Louis ****ing Tomlinson too. What a crap panel. The pic didn't load and I assumed Louis Walsh was back :laugh:

In what world do ITV deem it acceptable to have Ayda Field as an X-Factor judge and not our Tulisa?

shazza is a redundant judge in the lives too, literal waste of space should be the other way round with her and ayda this series is going to flop so bad

Tulisa was **** tbh

I thought it was Walsh for a minute too til I saw the pic. :eyes:

Tomlinson is such a crap signing. He has 0 personality.

Only what she watched her Husband Struggle
in the recording studios.

She has been a LWHD itv member
even had her Husband on there

So ITV1HD has been doing Live testings , so to speak.

screaming at this reason

bye

Here's the thing, if they'd just put Sinitta on the panel this would've been half decent

She could've played the Louis Walsh role too

Well it looks like they got what they wanted from Louis :laugh2:

I'm screeching at 5%

You know that's just 1D's fans. If it wasn't for them the poll would probs have like 7 votes.