I wouldn't have chosen 5 for the girlband, a 3 or a 4 would have scalped. The white girl had no place there.

Enjoyed the vocal group episode. Shanice was my favourite

yes very good one, very difficult choices too since they were all so good


@Jigs, Tamara made it because she had proved Perrie wrong


i was surprised they picked Tyler last because that one they were most sure of having ''superstar potential'' so that one wasn't too difficult who they would choose as last girl in the group

I am OBSESSED with this instrument group. Harry is a ****ing star.

This was a tough category though, instruments are so diverse so to pin them to one group is difficult, they could’ve made 3/4 bands from that original band room and I think a combo of Dia, Morgan and I think his name was Billy (?) would’ve been gorgeous.

Billy was so good!

Speaking of Dia ...... how the **** did she manage to go 3 auditions without playing a single instrument :skull:

Yeah I thought the same, I understood at first but on the stage if she had an instrument I think she'd have stood out a fair bit more - she had 3 chances to show variety and really did nothing special

Especially coming in saying she can play Piano, Guitar AND Drums, itd have been nice to see what else she could’ve brought.

Matthew was ****ing horrendous.

He completely drags it down. Should have swapped with Billy

Shame Dia and Morgan crumbled because they and Jacob would have been just a three piece for me.

Billy went to my primary school lol, and his Sister was in my class

Lol so apparently they’ve reversed the decision, and also removed the Sunday episodes for the Live Weeks so supposedly 4 weeks of live shows.

Yea hasn't it been struggling to get 2m a episode?

It’s been kind of stuck at 1.9m, officials getting around 2.4m. Seems they’re playing it safe and just trusting it with the strictly viewer bonus.

Let's be honest, most of the final concert decisions have been pretty off the whole season. They definitely seem to be going for looks over talent which I didn't think they would.

So it didn’t do as much better than X factor.

it was up against BGT for weeks though

The format is so poor, the contestants singing the same song over and over Once they reach the band room stage is not a good idea

It seems all fluff and no substance

It airs before BGT, it overlaps by 10 mins

and now strictly will be at a later slot than normal too, because it ain't as important as Little Mix

i mean who's gonna tune in to strictly that late at 19:50 :skull:

I’ve agreed with all of the final concert decisions :skull:

Shame this isnt getting very high ratings but I didnt think it would. I have really enjoyed it so far. I also think some decent groups have been formed

The mixed group is the only decent one they've put together lol.

Matthew heavily brings down the instruments one and that girl group is dire.

So far I’d rank them
GirlGroup -9.5/10
Boyband-9/10
MixedGroup-8.5/10
Instrumental and vocal group-7/10

Welp

Instrument - 9/10
Mixed- 9/10
Boyband - 7.5/10
Girl Vocal - 7/10

Personally felt the instrumental group were crap I think billy should have made the group not Jacob - don’t wanna predict too early but for some reason I see them as the first group eliminated in the competition

The mixed group were really good but I feel like I’m missing something I don’t know what

So far out of all the groups shown so far I only see the boyband being the most successful

I think the girl vocal group being vocally the best though

Who knows maybe in the lives things could change