Come dine & rate my takeaway .

Are the producers worse than channel 5?
 

Tom was apparently in two shows .. and one of the housemates is apparently booked to do Deal or No Deal soon


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Yeah I saw a clip of Tom the weasel .

It was a promising start but on balance, I have to say I’m not impressed

Things they got right:

• Amazing house
• Diverse casting (though none of these housemates have “popped” and set the world alight)
• Someone finally telling Marcus to tone it down (I bet he was fuming)
• Consistent(ish) format

Things they got wrong:

• Censoring the live feed. They just don’t get it. House montages are supposed to be for things you GENUINELY can’t broadcast legally, same with bird noise. It’s not to cover up things for the highlights show! Expect the feed to be axed next year
• Vote to evict. Public still can’t be trusted. Also appalling format from a channel running mental health campaigns
• Building an (ugly) outdoor set again, and thus allowing the scum crowd back. Was time for a change to an indoor set up and a more intimate audience
• Incidental music on the edit. Stop trying to make nominations sound “tense”. The commercial music is annoying too but I can appreciate that’s what people expect from reality TV these days
• Far too many tasks. They’ve been ok but they’re constant
• Backdoor, pre-taped evictions. This is C5 bollocks
• Meddling with nomination thresholds
• Non-chronological editing, and splicing different shots together to literally fake scenes. This has been proven by the live feed so again, expect it to disappear!
• And finally, we’re back to civilian playing second fiddle to CBB. Do **** off

I have enjoyed it but I’m also over it and don’t care if it’s axed

They're definitely doing this to make sure Olivia wins . She will never have my vote.

The shortening of the time doesn't help if it gives production more incentive to overreact. If it is longer then they don't have to manipulate as much because there is more time for personalities to come forward and drama to develop.

Imo, the manipulation is closer to CBB and in that way very familiar. CBB was always heavyhanded (also short on time) with both the editing and meddling. That's just my memory of it and what I remember feeling at the time.

It sounds like you are saying more they have been typecast. I agree with that. It's almost like they prewrote the roles they wanted to fill and chose people who would be the most stable fit for that role and will hold their own.

There has to always be diversity in casting or else it is too of a boring show. But I agree here they crafted such obvious roles for each HM they knew what exactly was expected of them upon entering the house. Whereas before it took longer to get to know an HM in the past. They had to find their niche.

Edit/An aside: On introspection I think part of the reason Jenkin may have struggled is because he saw through this. Maybe subconsciously he saw he was being typecast as the group fatty as people started arriving. Then to have Olivia reject him so publicly in front of millioms on the first night. I don't know how much encouragement or meddling they are giving towards fitting their certain character, but that could have been the tough pill. I really felt there was something more to that than Jenkin being nominated for the punishment for him to have gone in his crabshell like that. (I really felt for him in that moment.)

I think because each person fit their niche so well, not only was there as much conflict (not necessarily bad?) from different communication styles.. but everyone communicated so well based on the filters they were given, it almost made future drama much more predictable. And also reactions.

I had thought they cast really well. Now I wonder if they cast too well. And also they messed up with background screens in a serious way...