I'm not going to judge her on this, I'm going to judge her on the fact that she's not a very good singer and has a lousy stubborn personality who couldn't take Simon's criticism.

If she wasnt a good singer she wouldnt have made the live shows

Emily can sing, none can say she can't. Her voice just isn't as good as say Niki or Rydian. She is still young, so her voice will get better.

Emily can sing!! Like Billy said, if she can't sing then why has she made the live shows?

well said there Callum :hug:

they have blocked it on you tube but im v supprised i thoght she was innocent but until i see it i cant judge

She was joking around. I don't think Emily would threaten to stab someone really, I mean c'mon I certainly think more of her than that.

She's been living off the back of a good audition for a while now, most of her other performances have been crap.The sooner she's off the better as far as I'm concerned.

Look what I just found:

http://www.freewebs.com/coldsoldierz/crewpicz.htm

Oh God shes a chav :(

Wow, didn't see that story coming :shocked:

-shrugs-
I couldn't care less.

She goes to the rival school to mine.
I'm really not surprised.

Loads of my mates actually know her.
So I might ask around to see if they know anything about it.

So, she is part of this gang she denies being part of?

Stupid girl.

Why is she stupid? For having friends?

She's not stupid, at all. People should judge her on her singing not her bloody personal life. So what if she's a chav? It's her decision at the end of the day, and we should respect that.

If she threatens people with knives, even if it's in jest, we shouldn't "respect" her at all. That's a sick sense of humour. My cousin was stabbed to death in some silly gang-related thingymabob, and knives aren't a laughing matter.

1) I already have judged her on her singing, which let's face it is pretty dire.

2) She invited us to judge her personal life the second she started whining on with her sob story. If we're allowed to give a say on the parts of her life that make her seem amazing and inspirational, we're also allowed to give a say on the parts that show her for the thug and the liar that she evidently is.

Shaun sorry to hear about that, but I know people who have said in gest Omg shut up I wish you were dead. Its the same thing, its AWFUL thing to say, but they didnt mean it. The person she said this to (the "terrified teenager") was laughing around with her.

Omg i never saw the video since it was taken down so i can't judge on it really but tbh playing around and threatening people with knifes is no laughing matter, since i asume she was laughing in the video.

Actually Ruth EVERYONE was laughing in the video, including the supposed "terrified teenager"

I totally understand where your coming from Shaun, and when knives and weapons become involved it turns serious, but what I'm trying to say here is that some people are blatantly disliking her just because of her personal life, and that to me is unfair.

I agree, and I'm sorry about your cousin.
The fact that children have been stabbed across Britain lately, and the government are cracking down on street crime shouldn't mean we have to respect her because she's on TXF. Even if she thinks its a joke, it's still a serious offence.

It happened in 2005 aswell. IM sure after stuff that Emily herself has been through seh has regretted what seh did, which doesnt make it right but still

OMG! I'm not saying 'respect her' all I'm saying is personally I think we should respect her decision if she wants to be a chav or whatever, and the end of day, it's up to her what she does.

Wow, that's a shock Who'd have thunk?