exactly

For me people go the opposite way, everyone says someone who is quite skinny and keeps themself in shape is ill or something along the lines, how offensive is that.

Nothing wrong with liking slim girls. peoples perception of slim is different to.


In terms of facts, she is probably considered on a bmi test as over weight.

Perfect girl
http://www.poptower.com/pic-12943/kellyanne-judd.jpg

I'd be willing to bet that Corin's bmi would class her as underweight Ben, and that's not healthy either.

Like I said, nothing against slim girls at all and fair play to them for keeping healthy and looking good, I like to do the same, but calling someone like Rachael fat just because she may be carrying a few extra pounds MAYBE...does not make her unhealthy and certainly not obese!

Rachael >

Look at all them bones sticking out, she in underweight which is just as bad as being overweight! Although Rach has a nice curvy figure.

My mum thinks she's fat but I don't see it. She has a nice curvy figure.

Bones sticking out are just as unattractive as flab imo.

She looks like she needs to go eat the entire McDonald's menu every day for a week.

That girls shoulders are wider than the rest of her! Women aren't supposed to be shaped like that.. oh and she obviously has implants..
I agree everybody likes different looks/shapes/sizes but to call somebody with a figure like Rachel's fat is downright offensive towards her! She's got a lovely body!

Im not saying she is unhealthy or obease..

What im saying is, she isnt slim particularly.

and she has quite big thighs and a bit of a belly thats all.


She has quite a small bum really.

She looks so much better there! Why lose all the weight?

http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/ph..._teese_021.jpg

so much better. <3

of course she's not fat!

what a stupid question.

she has a great figure.

I know you're not but some people in here are saying she's fat but she's so not.

Agreed she's not especially slim exactly, but she's curvy, with boobs and hips and a bum, the way women are meant to look. And I'm not knocking women who are naturally skinny btw. I know some people are just made that way.

I know she's not fat..... I was just trying to wind 'dan the lesbian' up ! Think it worked :dance:

.. oh ananother thing.. even if WAS fat (which she's not), what gives anybody the right to pass remark on it?! Do you know how hurtful that could be for somebody or how damaging for youngsters reading it and thinking they need to diet incase they become "fat"

Agreed with that 100%. I don't like Rachael at all but I read that she was actually really down on herself and her size until she met Beyonce and she told her she was beautiful and she should be proud of her figure. Telling people they need to look like Cheryl Cole for example in order to be 'sexy and attractive' is just so damaging, hardly any of us are ever going to look like that and nor should we need to! It's about being healthy and happy with yourself.

Perfect Pixie eh Joe. :wink:

I thought this thread could do with a bit of order. Pixie is the only one who can bring it.

she does look a bit anorexic in this picture
http://www.mtv.com/onair/rwrr_challe...yanne-0047.jpg

But you are in a sence.. with boobs and hips and a bum thats how women are meant to look
?


She has got quite a belly she needs definately to tone it. She would look far better, the size she is but with a more toned belly.

She isn't fat. She's just not a skinny b!tch. She might wobble a lil bit if you ******* her, but if you ******* her then you obviously don't mind. Sorry, this heat gives me a one-track mind.

She's lovely and everything BUT I think Rachael's figure is better.
Also is it just me... she has NO BELLYBUTTON! LOL

That's just my opinion then, but I'm sure a lot of women and men would agree with me. Women should look like women, not like little boys and calling someone like Rachael fat is just ridiculous.

I agree. My last girlfriend was REALLY skinny. It was like *******ing a pile of coathangers. My new missus, who actually isn't that new, is lovely and curvy and really does it for me.

I wish I was as fat !! no way is she ,shes got a good body ,vile attitude ,but still good body

not fat,
i don't really like her as a person.

She probably already does. What she needs to do is stop sticking her fingers down her throat.

Errr guys like this make me want to stop eating!

Shabby has a beer gut.

They all just need some more Pixie in their lives. I think shes pretty much perfect :D

Pretty soon size 8 will be fat -.-
I hate this world

Anyone with sense knows that shes not fat.

Bigger the better

Well she's supposedly a Beyonce lookalike, and Beyonce is well known for her enormous backside and thunder thighs.

That is very insulting though? can you not see that?

People dont have to "look like little boys" they can be skinny and still hot..


Although my view on this subject has changed quite a bit in recent months, i still feel its unfair to say things like that?

I know previously other people on this forum have said that they are not "real women" when they are skinny.

All i mean is being skinny you can still look like a woman, you can still look very sexy. As you can if your curvy to.

No she bloody well is not fat.

She's not fat at all.

wait.. im not sure.. i havent really seen her body... i wish she would
wear something more revealing so i could really tell... if she would ONLY
walk around in JUst her knickers...... wait.....
?