I'm not saying Paula is my type of girl. I'm just saying that stating "skinny is as healthy as being fat" is ridiculous. I have no problem at all with a woman with a tad extra baggage, but Josie is just flabby, with no curves.

I would love to see what you actually look calling other people fat when they are not thats is ridiculous

thats good you dont like her as its one less guy as competition for me gettin my hands on her :hugesmile:

I think she is attractive but people only think she is the most desirable woman on earth because she's famous. There are plenty of regular women walking around the streets with regular jobs who are better looking but they won't get any credit because they're not famous.

josie is my third fave and i think she is actually lovely lookswise. more girls should be supporting her I thunk... its great to see a larger lady out there with confidence!

It is actually true, look it up... And yes I mean being skinny, not anorexic either...

Going by your username you are obviously incredibly shallow, so yeah, I wouldn't expect any other comments really ;)

How come everytime someone brings up the word fat.. its followed by "at least she isnt stick thin" "least she isnt size zero"

You can be not fat and not unhealthily skinny!
There is quite a wide mid point there!

check out this girl

she is no1 most beautiful girl i seen, a true princess :hugesmile:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQ-ub...eature=related

and i picked her out to win from the very start of the competition :tongue:

Josie is a bit chubby, but not exactly fat.
She has a pretty face. :P

maybe it because no one can say she is beautiful without someone following by saying she is fat? people make comments to be negative and others make a comment to be postive as a come back. Simple really?

Have you seen the top of her legs? They're massive.

she has a cellulite ass.

amazing eyes though.

i thought she'd have bigger boobs than that...

whats up with the picture? its censored!!

oooo matron:hugesmile:

She's a bit out of proportion (boobs to hips ratio is totally out lol) but I still think she looks better than Caoimhe, who looks like a boy and Corin who is just too skinny with fake boobs.

Plus she has a lovely face, gorgeous eyes and nice smile.

Even those stats would be seen by some to be too thin or too big, depending on the height of the girl.

Josie is a bit fat - Women in the UK are having a very hard time facing up to the fact that the majority of them are overweight - Especially by slagging off 'skeletal' looking celebrities in the papers, who are in fact a healthy weight.

So many people in this country are overweight nowadays that they feel it's justified because 'so is everyone else'.

Anyway, on topic - Josie is a bit chunky, but I would tap her all over. She might not be as pretty as Ife or Caoimhe but she's definitely more ****able. Especially when she was wearing those glasses and the big gold earrings and the chavvy jacket. Big dirty country girl. Hot.

edit : Where's the unedited boobs pic?

another thread about josies weight? really? lol people need to get an original thought going on around here.

Can we get past Josie's weight? I don't really give a care. She is a fantastic housemate, makes me laugh, and seems remarkably genuine and well-adjusted compared to the others. If she wants to show her breasts and have a laugh, let her. It gives no one right to go on about her weight. People should spend less time commenting on her weight and more time looking at what her positives are (or figuring out that they are incredibly shallow).

*steps down from soapbox*

:cheer:

:dance:

For those that say she isn't "fat," how exactly would you describe her weight?

I'm not choosing sides, I'm asking genuinely. I don't really think it matters. No one is talking about the guys' weights.

yet you want to talk about Josie's? :bored:

Lets just move on to a more interesting topic maybe?

shut up

u

Shabby & Camho makes me wanna puke :yuk:

Can I use your signature pic? :P

I'd say chubby, or big, but they are just kinder versions of fat. But she does definately have sexy curves ... It all comes down to shape really, not size or weight. You could be a size 8 and either look like a skinny boy or a little minx - alternatively you could be a size 18 and look like a fat mess or an amazonian godess ... All depends on the girls individual shape IMO!

Love this one!x

I don't mind the use of the word 'fat', but I am amazed we are still seeing live threads about Josies' body weight at week 4.

Really? I'm not ... I expect it will continue for the rest of the series. It's all part of the show :spin:

I just thought people would have found somehting else by now... this just seems... done.

I mean, has anyone else really actually got anything else new to say?

I guess the fact that people are still attacking Jose on her weight is a good sign though... it shows they very little else in their arsenal they can use to try and make her look bad :D

i suppose she only looks slim or 'not fat' to morbidly obese people, what is all that sucking of the thumbs shes doing? has she read some obscure pyschology book about substituting things to go in the mouth, while next to her object of desire.

See? Exactly the same stuff as was being posted on Day 3 :joker:



The fact that in a month they have had nothing else to add to it speaks volumes about how well she is doing, and how desperate the attack has become :D

i aint attacking her, shes one of my favourites, not very good at interpreting things are you?

I apologise for the misreading :)

Are people seriously still bangin' on about Josies weight.....geezus