ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)
-   BB11 (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=551)
-   -   Dave In His Wheelchair (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=151024)

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574806)
This is exactly what I mean! You don't know how he pays his bills - you just assume instead!

According to a friend of his who comes on here sometimes, and possibly something he may have said himself, he gets a wage/salary from some sort of sponsors for this 'group'! Don't know the ins and outs - but the point being - none of us do!

Without facts - noone should be making such unproven, unfounded allegations - they are character assassination and potentially extremely dangerous to his 'reputation' - whatever individuals currently happen to think of that! Just comes down to personal likes and dislikes based on people's individual views, nothing more!

It means how does he draw a wage?

If he is making money from his falsehoods and nonsense then someone or someones are being exploited.


"he gets a wage/salary from some sort of sponsors for this 'group'!"


bingo

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by housemate (Post 3574811)
I agree that it does shame Christianity (in my opinion)
Surely one of daves little mates (in the vid) could have had a placard stating that Dave was actually able bodied? The chair was obviously used as an advertising slogan for his cause, the honourable thing (if he wasn't presenting himself as disabled) would have been to make this clear to the people he spoke to?
Put it this way, if I encountered a Monk in a wheelchair, the last thought to come to mind would be that he was anything other than a disabled Monk!

You have a valid point there - but there is a big difference between lack of insight, stupidity (whatever you want to call it) and out and out dishonest intentions and ripping people off!

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574820)
You have a valid point there - but there is a big difference between lack of insight, stupidity (whatever you want to call it) and out and out dishonest intentions and ripping people off!

What other conclusion would anyone who saw him make?:conf:


it was exploitative and dishonest

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3574765)
Here is the problem:

Yes, I posted this for fingers and others and my complaint is that this type of behavior is shaming Christianity. The drunken nonsense is the problem.

Fingers and a few others don't care about that but instead are hoping to convince people that the video depicts David faking some disease or injury that has him in a wheelchair in order to 'get money'.
Wrong.
That is not what is happening there. It is not a video of David pretending to be in a wheelchair to get money.

So now what has happened is that Fingers is becoming as guilty as the thing he claims to be against: deception, misrepresentation, fooling people.

Excellent post!

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet (Post 3574816)
It means how does he draw a wage?

If he is making money from his falsehoods and nonsense then someone or someones are being exploited.


"he gets a wage/salary from some sort of sponsors for this 'group'!"


bingo

No it isn't bingo - still supposition!

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet (Post 3574825)
What other conclusion would anyone who saw him make?:conf:

it was exploitative and dishonest

Conclusions, assumptions - we keep coming back to that! No actual facts!

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574838)
Conclusions, assumptions - we keep coming back to that! No actual facts!

he does not have a job

his "minister" moniker is not recognised by any authority (ie it is self proclaimed)

He has no job

he makes his money by exploiting gullible people to donate to him



His whole "ministry" is based on earning him a wage

housemate 29-07-2010 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574820)
You have a valid point there - but there is a big difference between lack of insight, stupidity (whatever you want to call it) and out and out dishonest intentions and ripping people off!

Im absolutly certain that Dave doesn't do this for kicks .. if he was collecting money on the spot or not, he clearly wanted to draw people in to his version of Faith. There isn't an organisation on Earth that survive on fresh air, the people he 'recruits' have to contribute.
Judging from his travel schedule alone (which he has mentioned dozens of times IN the house, I don;t have to assume, its clearly doing very well.

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet (Post 3574825)


it was exploitative and dishonest

An excellent point.

People are more likely too empathize with someone who is in a wheelchair: Exploitative

He doesn't need a bloody wheelchair: Dishonest

Beso 29-07-2010 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet (Post 3574852)
he does not have a job

his "minister" moniker is not recognised by any authority (ie it is self proclaimed)

He has no job

he makes his money by exploiting gullible people to donate to him



His whole "ministry" is based on earning him a wage

why do you need an authority to recognise what you believe in?

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet (Post 3574852)
he does not have a job

his "minister" moniker is not recognised by any authority (ie it is self proclaimed)

He has no job

he makes his money by exploiting gullible people to donate to him



His whole "ministry" is based on earning him a wage

Self-proclaimed in not illegal or necessarily immoral! That is how many religions often start!

There you go with your assumptions and conclusions again! If you have any facts, produce them!

I thought not!

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3574883)
An excellent point.

People are more likely too empathize with someone who is in a wheelchair: Exploitative

He doesn't need a bloody wheelchair: Dishonest

How is it excellent - it isn't based on fact - just supposition!

ElProximo 29-07-2010 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by housemate (Post 3574811)
I agree that it does shame Christianity (in my opinion)
Surely one of daves little mates (in the vid) could have had a placard stating that Dave was actually able bodied? The chair was obviously used as an advertising slogan for his cause, the honourable thing (if he wasn't presenting himself as disabled) would have been to make this clear to the people he spoke to?
Put it this way, if I encountered a Monk in a wheelchair, the last thought to come to mind would be that he was anything other than a disabled Monk!
The Drunk on the Lord nonsense is surely the same thing? An illusion whose sole purpose is to convince?

I agree. The idea is that Dave was in such drunken ecstasy that he couldn't walk and they needed to push him around in the wheelchair.
They do believe he was temporarily disabled.
I think most people see it and suppose it is some drunk nutters taking the piss.

Either way, the thing here was not collecting donations. They were not asking for money or taking money.
Fingers seems to be doing her best to convince as many as possible he was pretending to be disabled to get donations from people.
They were not.
Someone here even suggested he be reported for defrauding people but in fact they were not taking money from anyone.

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3574937)
I agree. The idea is that Dave was in such drunken ecstasy that he couldn't walk and they needed to push him around in the wheelchair.
They do believe he was temporarily disabled.
I think most people see it and suppose it is some drunk nutters taking the piss.

Either way, the thing here was not collecting donations. They were not asking for money or taking money.
Fingers seems to be doing her best to convince as many as possible he was pretending to be disabled to get donations from people.
They were not.
Someone here even suggested he be reported for defrauding people but in fact they were not taking money from anyone.

Again - good post!

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574921)
How is it excellent - it isn't based on fact - just supposition!

He is using a wheelchair in the video. FACT. Also he isn't disabled and dosen't need a wheel chair FACT.

ElProximo 29-07-2010 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3574952)
Again - good post!

I'm on a roll with you Wombai lol

*dont worry.. im sure i will infuriate you later but for now we are on the same wavelength i think hehe

Here is the start of a David Wheelchair thing in Guilford:


WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3574977)
I'm on a roll with you Wombai lol

*dont worry.. im sure i will infuriate you later but for now we are on the same wavelength i think hehe

Here is the start of a David Wheelchair thing in Guilford:


We are! :hugesmile:

I think the points you made about him being in a wheelchair because he was drunk with god, and therefore, unable to walk properly, made it all make more sense - it was simply a symbolic gesture!

Nothing to do with an intention to take the piss out of disabled people, as some have tried so hard to have us all believe! At worst people could accuse the stunt of being in poor taste - but not the same thing at all!

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3575043)
We are! :hugesmile:

I think the points you made about him being in a wheelchair because he was drunk with god, and therefore, unable to walk properly, made it all make more sense

That dosen't make sense

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 11:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3575052)
That dosen't make sense

It does! Where does the term 'legless' come from? So drunk you are unable to stand, nevermind walk! It makes perfect sense!

Kitten 29-07-2010 12:10 PM

the scary thing is that none of you actually have a clue what ur talking about. Dave taking advantage of disabled ppl and taking money off them? i don't think so. where did this idea even come from? what's wrong with u all, he's the most genuine guy in there. everyone else has cracked by now, can't u accept that Dave is just a nice guy?

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 12:11 PM

Its the, drunk on the "lord" bit that dosen't make sense

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3575124)
Its the, drunk on the "lord" bit that dosen't make sense

That one is a bit harder to explain - but is a big part of their belief system - but I can get the logic of it - just about! :hugesmile:

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 12:19 PM

I would imagine that he is very careful about anyone finding out about his, ahem, "income stream"

it will never be videoed that is for sure

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3575134)
That one is a bit harder to explain - but is a big part of their belief system - but I can get the logic of it - just about! :hugesmile:

I suppose I'll never get it, so i'm going to stop trying.
I'm not aiming this at anyone in particular but:

When someone can show me any case, where, under reasonable scientific conditions, it has been proven, that someone who believes something so much, become physically disabled, completely incoherent, I will then take back everything I have ever said about Dave.

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3575169)
I suppose I'll never get it, so i'm going to stop trying.
I'm not aiming this at anyone in particular but:

When someone can show me any case, where, under reasonable scientific conditions, it has been proven, that someone who believes something so much, become physically disabled, completely incoherent, I will then take back everything I have ever said about Dave.

you wont get it as it is fictitious

hence the only people who do pretend to get it are the needy and gullible


think of it as a numpty identifier

housemate 29-07-2010 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kitten (Post 3575116)
the scary thing is that none of you actually have a clue what ur talking about. Dave taking advantage of disabled ppl and taking money off them? i don't think so. where did this idea even come from? what's wrong with u all, he's the most genuine guy in there. everyone else has cracked by now, can't u accept that Dave is just a nice guy?

In a word No! He is immoral in the House and immoral out of it.
my opinion is based on what I see and hear on BB and what I see and hear him doing out of the house.
I don't intend or expect to sway anyone elses opinions about Dave but I am happy that I'm not the only one who finds Dave repulsive.
Genuine you say? What part of being able to cure cancer or stab his (so called) friends in the back is that then?

ElProximo 29-07-2010 12:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3575169)
When someone can show me any case, where, under reasonable scientific conditions, it has been proven, that someone who believes something so much, become physically disabled, completely incoherent, I will then take back everything I have ever said about Dave.

Trying to add a bunch of talk of 'scientific proof' is lame because you can dismiss anything except maybe maths,
however,
If you need to know then you might look no further than Derren Brown although others have worked with this too.
You bet.. yes indeed people can work themselves into euphoric ecstatic states through self-induced psychosomatic states.

You may have also seen (in life or on television) where someone in massive mental/emotional distress has lost their ability to stand.
Upon news the husband has died the woman becomes hysterical and seconds later her legs give out.. relatives must hold her up.

I was reading about a thing in wars 'shell shock' where men.. due to psychological trauma had become paralyzed.
There was no actual physical damage to their legs but traumatic fear etc.. they were literally 'scared stiff' and unable to walk or move.

Not exactly the same thing but here Brown shows how people can be convince they are drunk and their bodies will act accordingly:

Crimson Dynamo 29-07-2010 12:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575301)
Trying to add a bunch of talk of 'scientific proof' is lame because you can dismiss anything except maybe maths,
however,
If you need to know then you might look no further than Derren Brown although others have worked with this too.
You bet.. yes indeed people can work themselves into euphoric ecstatic states through self-induced psychosomatic states.

You may have also seen (in life or on television) where someone in massive mental/emotional distress has lost their ability to stand.
Upon news the husband has died the woman becomes hysterical and seconds later her legs give out.. relatives must hold her up.

I was reading about a thing in wars 'shell shock' where men.. due to psychological trauma had become paralyzed.
There was no actual physical damage to their legs but traumatic fear etc.. they were literally 'scared stiff' and unable to walk or move.

Not exactly the same thing but here Brown shows how people can be convince they are drunk and their bodies will act accordingly:

precisely

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 12:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by housemate (Post 3575206)
In a word No! He is immoral in the House and immoral out of it.
my opinion is based on what I see and hear on BB and what I see and hear him doing out of the house.
I don't intend or expect to sway anyone elses opinions about Dave but I am happy that I'm not the only one who finds Dave repulsive.
Genuine you say? What part of being able to cure cancer or stab his (so called) friends in the back is that then?

They all stab each other in the back - even Josie and JJ do it to each other (and a lot more frequently) so to use that as a reason to call him immoral is a bit lame to say the least!

housemate 29-07-2010 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3575322)
They all stab each other in the back - even Josie and JJ do it to each other (and a lot more frequently) so to use that as a reason to call him immoral is a bit lame to say the least!

I stand corrected .. as a man of the cloth it is immoral to hold the bible in one hand and defame those he professes to Love.
It is a gross insult to his Faith, my Faith and infact any Faith at all.

flamingGalah! 29-07-2010 01:06 PM

I find it absolutely hilarious that Daves fans on here will defend ANYTHING he does no matter how distasteful! The fraud is being wheeled around in a wheelchair & they say there is nothing wrong with that & try to come up with ridiculous reasons as to why it's acceptable...

It is WRONG & there is NO acceptable reason why an able bodied person should be wheeled about in a wheelchair...

The man is a disgrace & MUST BE EVICTED :xyxwave:

WOMBAI 29-07-2010 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flamingGalah! (Post 3575385)
I find it absolutely hilarious that Daves fans on here will defend ANYTHING he does no matter how distasteful! The fraud is being wheeled around in a wheelchair & they say there is nothing wrong with that & try to come up with ridiculous reasons as to why it's acceptable...

It is WRONG & there is NO acceptable reason why an able bodied person should be wheeled about in a wheelchair...

The man is a disgrace & MUST BE EVICTED :xyxwave:

Not into symbolic gestures then! :joker:

housemate 29-07-2010 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flamingGalah! (Post 3575385)
I find it absolutely hilarious that Daves fans on here will defend ANYTHING he does no matter how distasteful! The fraud is being wheeled around in a wheelchair & they say there is nothing wrong with that & try to come up with ridiculous reasons as to why it's acceptable...

It is WRONG & there is NO acceptable reason why an able bodied person should be wheeled about in a wheelchair...

The man is a disgrace & MUST BE EVICTED :xyxwave:

I just really wish I could understand where they are coming from ... Do they approve of Daves choices or are they just hell bent on playing Devils advocate?

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 01:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575301)
Trying to add a bunch of talk of 'scientific proof' is lame

I still require it

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575301)
You bet.. yes indeed people can work themselves into euphoric ecstatic states through self-induced psychosomatic states.

Yes, mentally deficient people

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575301)
You may have also seen (in life or on television) where someone in massive mental/emotional distress has lost their ability to stand.
Upon news the husband has died the woman becomes hysterical and seconds later her legs give out.. relatives must hold her up.

That is an extremely traumatic event and is a bad comparison.

David is not scared stiff, maybe a little mentally deficient

housemate 29-07-2010 01:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3575398)
Not into symbolic gestures then! :joker:

Lol!! Are you actually being serious, whats wrong with a Cross? Is it possibly that a Crucifix would be too obvious?

ElProximo 29-07-2010 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Late for the Party (Post 3575402)
I still require it

You can't handle it.

Quote:

Yes, mentally deficient people
Nope. It's better pulled off by more intelligent people. I think deficient ones can do it too.
The main thing is that you now agree this can happen. I feel better knowing you are just a little more educated.

Shasown 29-07-2010 01:17 PM

If you look at his videos, there are signs in some that say Free Healing. He offers blessings which he claims are from "God" and that god can cure people or at least make their lives better.

Him using a wheelchair is probably due to the drunk state he claims God's Love puts him in, or as apparent in one video as an attractor to the public, he doesnt claim to be physically unable to walk. (Careful editing?).

If he did make claims of being able to cure people and asked for money he would open himself up for prosecution under Consumer Protection Regulations. Similarly if he started diagnosing illness he would also be open under the Medical Act 1983.

The important thing to remember legally is that saying he did cure someone and saying he can cure someone are two entirely different things, one allows you to verify his claim if you want to. The other allows him to hide behind "the God will provide the cure" defence.

The form of healing he is offering is akin to Spiritual Healing and Reiki etc, which are recognised alternative therapies and are legal.

In my opinion he is not a lot different to buskers on the street an annoyance to some and entertaining to others.

Late for the Party 29-07-2010 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575439)
You can't handle it.

You can't provide it


Quote:

Originally Posted by ElProximo (Post 3575439)
The main thing is that you now agree this can happen. I feel better knowing you are just a little more educated.

Glad you feel better. It still isn't the true in daves case

flamingGalah! 29-07-2010 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WOMBAI (Post 3575398)
Not into symbolic gestures then! :joker:

I'm not into a piss taking ex druggie buffoon claiming he can cure cancer whilst being wheeled around Guildford high street, wearing a monks robe & laughing like a deranged hyena, no...

housemate 29-07-2010 01:27 PM

He is doing this in the name of God, not as an alternative Health Practioner.
He wasn't (as far as I'm aware) asking for donations on that street but he was asking people to join his Organisation ... as I have said previously, these sects, or whatever you choose to call them cannot run on fresh air.
I always give money to Buskers, Big Issuers and down and outs and the Sick ....or anybody in need come to that... these are generally the people who are most likely to reach out for any chance of hope and whom Davids Sloshfests and offers of salvation appear to be aimed at.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.