not like it will make her voice any worse than it already is

Even though she was better last week I have got to agree with this.

Jade had to sing last week and she got criticised from the judges for her performance. Lucy should have to perform as well, if she is ill, that is her hard luck.

If athletes are ill they don't get put through to the next round no matter who they are.

This is meant to be a competition :cloud:

what exactly is up with her? i mean if shes got the runs or being sick well she actually wouldnt be able to perform would she? but if it is flu or sore throat then its not fair as jade had to sing last week and i think rylan was ill too wasnt he? oh and kye? their dropping like flies

But if her voice is completely gone she would just be on stage not singing, would you expect her to sing & no sound whatsoever to come out?

Just need Ella, Jade and Kye to be ill now

I get what your saying but I honestly think she's faking her illness as she couldn't pull the theme off.

She was out at Mahiki partying up. If she was well enough to do that then she should have to perform. If she got ill after that then it's tough luck and likely due to her late night.

thought this said lucy has done dianna vickers

:laugh: ^

I like Lucy but this is unfair as Jade was poorly last week and performed and others have been poorly in the past XFactors,and had to carry on,so imo it's not fair

This is unfair!! Jade performed after losing her voice? But i love Lucy so happy she's through to next week =D

Maybe she has a temperature? :conf:

She has severe flu...

I've had it, it's ****ing awful, you literally don't want to get out of bed, nevermind perform for 8 million people.

Ever heard of the show must go on...if she has lost her voice, fine, but other than that she should be going out there....

But you're male

Maybe it was just normal flu and I was being dramatic then.

What about if she is successful and touring, one night she is ill all her fans have paid and are waiting will she cancel then? Obviously she does not want this enough. Plus its funny how Tulisa's acts are ill all the time :rolleyes:

lmao. People will find anything they can to slag off Tulisa.

if its only flu then she shud have been on there. she cud have lay on a bed or something and sang about having the flu lol

No I was just making an observation I would've said the same had it been any other judge.

Real flu is really awful, you literally struggle to even move. People these days seem to think flu is just a sniffle but if its actually flu its much much worse.

That said she should still have been part of the vote, even if she didnt perform IMO.

:worship:

I am all for compassion in things but in a show like this at the 'live' finals stage, no one should get 'byes' to the next week.
If they cannot perform and are really ill or have something far more pressing that they have to be released to go and deal with so cannot perform at all on the night,then they should forfeit their place in the live finals,for me they should anyway.

weather she goes this week or any other it dosn't matter, she aint gonna win.
she's ill and couldn't perform, lay off the girl, she hasn't killed anyone.

She should have performed....it's not fair if she doesn't.