From an entertainment value perspective I see where you're coming from but I prefer Aisleyne to all of them and Deana to Makosi and Nikki
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/...32_468x655.jpg

(and I prefer like 20 HMs to Nikki oop)

I would agree if we're comparing their BB stints from 2006/7. But Aisleyne's just a tragic mess now, who's z-list fame has gone to her head.

is it seen as like cool to hate nikki now or something

!!

And Aislyene is nawt better then Charley

Or maybe people just don't like her :shrug:

True

Ais BB16 > Ais BB7

then they're wrong

anyway this is purely from entertainment perspective as it states in the OP

I don't hate ha I just found her irritating at times (especially after she came back) which is why she isn't up there with Makosi, Charley, Aisleyne etc. as the best ever HMs for me

Nothing will ever beat Ais BB7. <3

Now sis...

I only judge housemates in their stints in the house and I preferred Ais's progression more than Charlé's stint marginally

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/cust...r75182_141.gif

they're my top three personal favourites too

nikki will forever beat aisleyne in every series she's been in (nod)

Preach sis

It's not even based on personal favourites so saying no to any of them is not possible because they factually ARE the best three entertainment wise.

Sorry this chick wasn't to keen on ais bullying Lea in BB7

Fair enough

Nikki was always trash and that will never change imo.

Aisleyne is my fourth favourite ever though

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/cust...ar82167_54.gif

You used to list her in your top 10 along ith Makosi :joker:

I do too. But it's hard to not judge Aisleyne for her tragicness given she seems to project it in every BB related/BBOTS stint she's in nowadays, which her original stint is why she's even there in the first place. To think 9 years ago, she stood up to someone chucking a glass of water at an older lady, and then Aisleyne goes and does it herself to someone who's like over a decade younger than her on national TV. It's just disappointing.

I still really like Nikki. If we're judging ha for ha first 8 week stint in BB7 and BB16 then she's a top 10 HM easy, but her comeback ruined her slightly for me
http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/cust...ar82167_54.gif

At least you love Lea :clap1:

Underrated enigma <3

Nikki in BB16 was seriously flawless :flutter:

HM Perfection

Deana >>>>

Why is BB16 Nikki getting all the praise?

UBB Nikki is actually the one time I was fully rooting for her and is definitely her best appearance imo. Her BB7 appearance pre re-entering was okay. Her re-entering was awful. By BB16, I was just bored of her. But she was better than Helen or Brian and even Aisleyne at one point (with her cosying up to Danny)

Justice for Nikki's re entry, I get that she shouldn't have been there but at least she brightened it up (her anger at not getting an award is underrated)

We should add Deana into the titles! Another person who made a season

BB7 > BB16 > UBB > BB7 Return

BB16 Nikki as FAR better than the rest of the returnee's put together. She fully clocked Helen better than anyone else has ever done.

I would've preferred Grace or Lea to go back in tbh. Nikki re-entering was just her fawning over Pete for the entire last week. :sleep:

Still bitter at Mikey going in over Sam

Mikey was a dumb choice. Not only was he a dullard for 11 weeks. But he'd just been evicted. Like give someone else a chance.

Jayne >>

NO Lisa >>

When Nikki re-entered she just attached herself to Pete and threw lots of fake tantrums in a transparent attempt to get votes and I wasn't here for it. Especially when comparing it to her more genuine hilarious tantrums in the start of BB7.

This.

Pikki bored the **** out of me. And her treatment of Aisleyne was rather disgusting too.

Her leaving to boos in fifth place (after originally coming out to heroic cheers) whilst Aisleyne leaves 3rd :lovedup:

The returnee twist shouldn't have happened (or at least the returnee shouldn't have entered the main house as a full HM)
http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/cust...ar82167_54.gif

Oop I loved returnee-Nikki <3