Yes, that was my point. It's all sorted out already but it's just annoying that people are calling her a liar, she could have most certainly gotten a bruise from that.

Why lol?

It's nothing more than a Rorschach test... It's blurry and unclear enough for people to see whatever they want to see in it.

I prefer the fact that BB made it clear that Deb was lying to be my guide on this.

More annoying than a someone falsely accusing another of assault, and keeping the lie up until they are proven wrong?

I think not.

Lying about something like this is scummy move. It actually could have had legal implications beyond the house. It was dirty and dishonest.

People will see what they want,you could also say it looks like hanna pushed Charlotte and Ellie over from that gif,lol

She didn't know it was an accident though. :nono:

That's good enough to say she punched her then..:joker:

Since Ellie was stumbling backward it's pretty obvious what happened. The sisters are quick to jump on things and assume the worse and be a victim.

It wasn't even an accident, it just didn't happen. that gif is stupidly grainy and indistinct, people are just projecting what they want to see on it. If clearer images come up, I will re evaluate, but based on that? No.

No assault took place, at all. Deb maintaining that it did makes her a liar. Attempting to weaponise it to actively damage another person with an extremely serious accusation makes her scum.

ffs look at the dumb ass gif again....ellies hand is well behind hannahs back so from the side she would be at least 6 inches behind her. Are you all now saying bb cameras are nowhere near as good as our 2 inch square fuzzy 2mb gif.

Mate you can clearly see her hand touching Hannah's face, why else would she turn.

I hope they send the police in live on Thursday to arrest Ellie as she is evicted

Unless you have access to BB's high definition slowmo close up footage then you cannot make that call. Apologies if you do work as a producer in BB. :)

The scary thing is that if they had been on the outside with no cameras, the sisters would have pushed this false accusation to the end and seen the law involved. They are that deeply messed up.

Thank god BB made it clear that they were lying.

I'm sure you do prefer that

Of course. Facts over feelings and agendas always.

Okay, I am going to download the episode in HD and make a zoomed gif just for the haters

Haters is a personal attack, please keep it to the HMs, not FMs.

But, yes, please. I am more than open to seeing it clearly and re evaluating if needed.

unless you have multiple camera angles its of no help

If you watch the HD clip she turns and tells Ellie to "shut up". Not what you would say if you thought you had been hit.

In doing so she knocks Elllie backwards and Charlotte dives in between them.

Shh, don't come here with your accurate observations.

BB have this fight from a few different angles.

No way would they lie about it to make Hannah look bad. I think they could get into a lot of trouble for that if Hannah came out and saw this fuzzy GIF that apparently proves Ellie did hit her (I genuinely cannot see it :umm2: ) and then found out bb 'lied' to her about being punched in the face...

The brusing likely occured from when Deborah elbowed her in the face a few seconds after this gif. She did it twice, and one time looked very hard :/ Obviously by mistake though