The problem is lili you can't speak on behalf of everybody. I reckon the BH would be pretty peeved as would the usual's in The Den.

As long as the BH is not closed, it sounds cool. If the BH is closed, we'll all get somewhere else and it will be worse for everyone so it's up to you.

it took me ages to read too jack.

On the other hand we have this great big bloody list on the first page.

Take a peek, if you will.

You just did play with words! You have been doing it throughout the 'debate'!

How can I not respond to such false comments!

Well I did say that 'good we will find out'. Had a brainwave and had to post it!

As lili said have a post for EVERYBODY to post in. No more devides!

I have seen it. Its just another example of tension on this forum... the more you guys protest then the less likely they will stop.

Not really. The daft linguo would stop, for one. Your not monsters, I don't think anybody cares if you all 'get somewhere else'.

But the fact that you are bigging up the threat of your own people getting into other threads as an argument for keeping the BH open does say something...

No I didn't play on words. You did and people saw I with the '4 years' comment you twisted so badly. I didn't get the exact term but the idea is the same: don't try to teach something you clearly aren't able to apply to yourself.

ME!!!!

Nothing yet - got caught up on this damn thing! Going to treat myself with something nice soon! :joker:

It'd never stop and you know it is true. BH thread or not, we'll still have our own fun and people could join if they want to. The whole 'one social' thread will fail because we'll never get along.

I made a poll. Feel free to add comments too. It's worth discussing.

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru...d.php?t=125077

The Knights thing is a joke- obviously we all know that we are on a forum and not running around a battlefield in the 15th Century.

As for some members going in other threads and agreeing with everything other BH members say, I don't know about that because I hardly read any other threads nowadays.

And I'm against all the threads being merged, and I'm sure most BH members and people that post regularly in The Den would be aswell. The BH was made because all members have a lot of things in common and like to talk between each other and not have things that we aren't interested in posted all over the thread, so merging them would defeat the purpose as to why we made the thread.

And as for the list on the first page, that hasn't been updated for ages and I'm all for that being deleted.

That's a good start. It's nice to see people willing to compromise David.

I'm for it to be deleted too. We don't do that anymore to be honest. I couldn't agree more to what you said.

I'm taking you out. My shout! :hugesmile: Well played fraulein.

Well if the memberlist is willing to be deleted, then I see no reason why it shouldn't stay.

I'm not trying to speak for everyone. I'm trying to gather opinions and I'd think majority vote would have some value.

If anyone doesn't want ONE thread, that shows their unwillingness to integrate in my opinion.

why do members keep comparing the den to the brotherhood, they have about the same popularity but the similarity ends there. the den is just a thread where people can talk to each other without sticking to one subject. the only rules are the ones set by the admins.

I knew when I posted that, that you might think I meant you singlely but I meant in general. 1 person doesn't know what everybody else wants. (sorry)

Try creating the group and see what happens. Its a valid idea

It will only work if everyone agrees to lock the old ones, and possibly have a week-long-trial of a new social thread. We could have someone neutral (such as yourself) choosing a neutral name for it, and everyone could just use it for non-specific chat.

An offer not to be refused! :joker:

Deleting the list will dissolve a lot of tension, good idea David.

Closing the BH would cause havoc.. I'm not going to be responsible for it as I don't see it bring ANY solution to the problem. The BH members wouldn't be happy and neither would the other people on the forum as there would be chaos.

I don't mind making a name up.