Lol thats alright, I love dunne, no nonsense and hope he becomes our captain soon..bit surprised keano is irelands captain over him

[rquote=2618946&tid=133229&author=setanta]You're really underrating Dunne there Nathan.[/rquote]

No your just OVER rating him

http://d.yimg.com/i/ng/sp/empics/200...2009003909.jpg

hero

Notice as soon as everton got rid off dunne they aint been in any Relegation battles :joker:

Very poor and misleading argument. He was a kid when he was there and left after two seasons where they didn't fall into relegation battle and was still only 21 at the time. Matured into a great centre-back and won player of the year with Man City for 4 years in a row, and part of that time was spent playing alongside Distin, a player now on the Everton books.

Distin is okay..
Dunne/Yobo are good..
Jagielka is quality..

:wavey:

Too early to suggest that Jagielka is quality. One season does not a great player make.

Hes had 2 good seasons though..

Jagielka has always been a Quality player

[rquote=2619054&tid=133229&author=setanta]Very poor and misleading argument. He was a kid when he was there and left after two seasons where they didn't fall into relegation battle and was still only 21 at the time. Matured into a great centre-back and won player of the year with Man City for 4 years in a row, and part of that time was spent playing alongside Distin, a player now on the Everton books.[/rquote]

This is why Yobo is twice the player dunne will ever be

Yes, very intelligent response. And you keep forgetting that Moyes tried to buy Dunne.

Just because David moyes tried to buy him doesn't mean i should rate him?

Am glad he didn't buy him we are much better off without him

That's not an argument. David Moyes wanted him as his replacement for Lescott and sure if Yobo and Jagielka are so good why was Distin or Dunne so necessary? They'd both walk onto that team.

Because they need back up i think..

Lescott and Jagielka played amazing together but they didnt have many to cover for them.

Once Jagileka is fully fit again he distin will probably be benched more.

we don't have that many center backs anyway hence why hibbert was playing center back on thursday night +Jag is still injured

Who did you expect everton to play at center back if we never brought distin? exactly. thats why distin was so necessary that and the fact he is a quality player and better then dunne

I think Distin will be playing when Jagielka comes back. Yobo and Jagielka will fight for other spot as long as the frenchman stays healthy.

distin isnt as good as jag and is about on par with yobo
Jag will be first team when fully fit.


And im so surprised benitez praising anoth manager :shocked: my gosh first tme he has done that!

When did he praise anyone? lol He's an arrogant little douche.

Distin's a bit old but still has a year or two left in him at a good club. You need a reliable old head in your team.

[rquote=2619418&tid=133229&author=.Andy.]we don't have that many center backs anyway hence why hibbert was playing center back on thursday night +Jag is still injured

Who did you expect everton to play at center back if we never brought distin? exactly. thats why distin was so necessary that and the fact he is a quality player and better then dunne

[/rquote]

Better than Dunne? Are you mad in the head? Why did Dunne win player of the year 4 years in a row at Man City then? Why was he Moyes' first choice as a replacement to Lescott?

[rquote=2619432&tid=133229&author=setanta][rquote=2619418&tid=133229&author=.Andy.]we don't have that many center backs anyway hence why hibbert was playing center back on thursday night +Jag is still injured

Who did you expect everton to play at center back if we never brought distin? exactly. thats why distin was so necessary that and the fact he is a quality player and better then dunne

[/rquote]

Better than Dunne? Are you mad in the head? Why did Dunne win player of the year 4 years in a row at Man City then? Why was he Moyes' first choice as a replacement to Lescott?[/rquote]

Didn't distin win the fa cup with pompey thought so. what did dunne ever do at man city fck all! zilth zero Nil!

And why did he win player off the year 4 years in a row... ermm maybe because there whole squad was shite and full off bellends like joey barton

[rquote=2619437&tid=133229&author=.Andy.][rquote=2619432&tid=133229&author=setanta][rquote=2619418&tid=133229&author=.Andy.]we don't have that many center backs anyway hence why hibbert was playing center back on thursday night +Jag is still injured

Who did you expect everton to play at center back if we never brought distin? exactly. thats why distin was so necessary that and the fact he is a quality player and better then dunne

[/rquote]

Better than Dunne? Are you mad in the head? Why did Dunne win player of the year 4 years in a row at Man City then? Why was he Moyes' first choice as a replacement to Lescott?[/rquote]

Didn't distin win the fa cup with pompey thought so. what did dunne ever do at man city fck all! zilth zero Nil!

And why did he win player off the year 4 years in a row... ermm maybe because there whole squad was s**** and full off bellends like joey barton [/rquote]

Lol. Distin played with him on the same team.

[rquote=2619448&tid=133229&author=setanta][rquote=2619437&tid=133229&author=.Andy.][rquote=2619432&tid=133229&author=setanta][rquote=2619418&tid=133229&author=.Andy.]we don't have that many center backs anyway hence why hibbert was playing center back on thursday night +Jag is still injured

Who did you expect everton to play at center back if we never brought distin? exactly. thats why distin was so necessary that and the fact he is a quality player and better then dunne

[/rquote]

Better than Dunne? Are you mad in the head? Why did Dunne win player of the year 4 years in a row at Man City then? Why was he Moyes' first choice as a replacement to Lescott?[/rquote]

Didn't distin win the fa cup with pompey thought so. what did dunne ever do at man city fck all! zilth zero Nil!

And why did he win player off the year 4 years in a row... ermm maybe because there whole squad was s**** and full off bellends like joey barton [/rquote]

Lol. Distin played with him on the same team.[/rquote]

He saw sense and fcked off to portsmouth where he actually won something

That still doesn't counter myargument on the merits of Dunne. Three times he beat Distin to player of the year for Man City. The had a great partnership and Moyes was keen on signing Dunne first. When he couldn't get him he opted for Distin. I think that there's enough evidence there to suggest that Dunne is up there with the best in the country.

He won player off the year 4 times at shitty city never won a cup..

yeah enough evidence there to prove he's up there with the best in the country