Regardless of whether he was allowed to talk to Lisa while near people or not. David said "No, this one" (about the camera) to somebody.

I do remember thinking to myself when David shouted 'Lisa Lisa Lisa' several times, that they could incur a fail for that, because yes they were allowed to speak to each other, but they were also told that they weren't allowed to reveal their identity in ANY way.

Him shouting her name could, if BB wanted to be really strict about it, mean that he's failed.

Not big enough of a deal for people on here to be arguing about it so much though surely? :tongue:

I agree Kitty and sure I found the whole thing so funny. Lisa walking exactly like she normally does took the buscuit for me.... still knew it was her in the costume lol.

I will not dispute the fact that they may have failed the task but the fail would be nothing to do with him saying "Lisa Lisa Lisa." It doesn't MATTER that we knew it was David because of his accent, he did not intentionally reveal who he was verbally. That's like saying he revealed who he was because you could tell there was a big bloke under the costume - OH NOEZ THAT MUST BE DAVID FROM BB!!!111one - uh, no. Doesn't work like that.

Saying thank you to a girl, saying "no, this one" about the camera to someone would be against the task rules, but not addressing Lisa in his normal accent around people. He didn't communicate who he was to the general public then.

I never said they should have failed because people recognised him from his accent etc, please read this it is a quote directly from the official ch4 bb website

Now tell me did they pass if he said thank you or anything else to a member of the public?

I wasn't replying to you :thumbs:

Oh and with regards to whether they passed/failed? I don't know. All I know is if they had it had nothing to do with the "Lisa Lisa Lisa" - I was AGREEING with you, if anything, that it would be the thank you/etc. to the girl/public.