no it didn't i should know i was the one who said it

But by saying no comment that is not a comeback to what I was saying. No comment is usually said when someone does not want to answer the question otherwise you would say something in responce.

There is no point debating this now because it's not possible to determine the who is right. What will you do if I am right though?

but your not, and you will relise i'm right when x-factor is on

You cannot say I am wrong because we don't know where she has come on the x-factor and we won't for a while. So I say she will not make the top 5 and say she will, we will so who is right then.

fine we'll wait and see weather she is good at singing or not then, i think she will be good and you don't we'll see who's right then

Message from Admin - can you not agree to disagree please.

Thats what I said aswell I thought she was only 24?:puzzled::puzzled:

I dont think Michelle being on X Factor is fair to the others in the show. Same as when Andy whats his name was on Pop Idol - he got through because people knew him and his sister. I think programmes like X Factor should be for complete unknowns.

If Michelle hasnt been offered a recording contract with all the publicity she has had then why think she has the talent to win X Factor.

Last year though Rowetta had already had her shot at stardom...so do you think that she doesn't deserve her record deal either? (Her album is out soon by the way,she got a deal with Gut Records)

I think that if she is a good singer and she is getting through based only on her singing then she deserves it just as much as anyone else...why not?The show is looking for a star and if she can fill that space then she deserves a chance just as much as anyone else IMO.

Frankly I don't like Michelle,never really have,but if she keeps me entertained of a Saturday Night so be it.

YAY I LOVED ROWETTA !!

Yeah she was cool!She has a song on the Mr and Mrs Smith soundtrack aswell which is a cover of Oasis Stop Crying Your Heart Out.

yep i read about in the paper

michelle was 24 in February so what group will she be in then???:puzzled:

Under 25s but i dont know who does that group as it might change. It was sharon last year

think it will be Louis' from what i've read:thumbs:

Yep she's definately in the 16-24 group....and apparently that's Louis' group?!

cool

And now Im being told that Sharon is her mentor...

Don't know what to believe really!Some are saying it's Louis,some Sharon.Well at least we know she is 24 so that puts her in the 16-24 group.

Some people are saying Louis some say Sharon..Lance do you know when BB date actully starts

BB date?
If you meant X Factor then it's August 20th.:hugesmile:

yeh thats what i meant sorry am tired

Rite so far this is wht I have gathered...

Michelle has made it to Boot Camp stage at least.

She is part of the 16-24 group and her mentor is either Sharon or Louis and is more likely Louis.Simon has the vocal groups group and Im guessing Louis has the uner 25s because Sharon had them last year.

Woah this is confusing

so simon will have vocals

michelle will win,
i'll be supporting her all the way!!!!

Do you know how many make each different bootcamp?

i never knew celebrities could go on the x-factor