I feel like this thread ought to deal with one thing at a time, I have so many opinions and I don't know where to begin, so I'll just start and maybe Smithy can take over and decide when we should move on :laugh: 'cause I think this is a pretty good thread idea, people can explain why they think something is hated on.
Lady GaGa I think is hated on because she debuted as this cool party girl type with her first couple of songs and I think she earned herself a certain type of crowd following. I didn't like that image, personally, but I know a lot of people did. Just Dance, Pokerface, LoveGame... she had a definite sound, image and popstar persona there. I don't know if that's who she "really" is, but that's how she presented herself to the world when she debuted.
I think the hate kicked in when she completely changed her image and started being weird, strange and made a point of being different, standing for difference, representing all that is alternative and different. It was a complete overhaul. Suddenly, the fanbase she appealed to originally was no longer who she wanted to appeal to, so I think that's where it started. The media jumped at the chance to poke fun at her because she was suddenly wearing meat dresses and Kermit the frog dresses and that was just fine by her because it strengthened her whole "I'm representing difference" aim. I don't know if that's who she really is either, because she's chopped and changed what she stands for so many times throughout her career already, and to be perfectly honest, it detracts from the extremely talented singer, songwriter and dancer that she is. I think I would like Lady GaGa if her talents were at the forefront of her pop career. But to me, a casual listener, it's all style over substance - because the style is just so over the top, that it takes away from what's really there behind the image. I think people hate her because it comes across as fake, changing what you stand for so dramatically, and I think people hate her because it comes across as fake, making a choice to stand out so flamboyantly in the way that she does.
|