ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)
-   CBB21 (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=725)
-   -   India clashes with Ginuwine as he says he wouldn’t date a transgendered woman (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=333086)

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 07:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vicky. (Post 9774623)
Tends to only be applied to lesbians. Its not just transactivists, a lot of 'normal' transgender people are the same. Lesbians are transphobic bigots as penises on transwomen are female body parts and as such, its the vagina they want so they are vagina fetishists and need to get over their bigotry.

Sounds mental, but its actually fairly common these days. Literally every lesbians friend I have has had an experience with a person like this.



Watch this, if you have spare time. Its all absolutely bat****.

I have learned much from you on this topic.
I’ve seen that Riley before on Youtube.He/she/they seems like they have alot of growing up to do.
This whole agenda seems to have gone from ‘we want acceptance’ to ‘we want to reshape the world around us and force you all to think,feel and be how we want or you’re an evil bigoted transphobe’

Vicky. 06-01-2018 07:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774658)
I have learned much from you on this topic.
I’ve seen that Riley before on Youtube.He/she/they seems like they have alot of growing up to do.
This whole agenda seems to have gone from ‘we want acceptance’ to ‘we want to reshape the world around us and force you all to think,feel and be how we want or you’re an evil bigoted transphobe’

Absolutely spot on. Its being driven by narcissistic arseholes, absolute fantasists advising the government on law changes that will effect everyone, but with no thought to anyone it will actually affect.

Meanwhile people grow even more deluded and start thinking biological sex is a social ****ing construct. It really annoys me sometimes when I see people I consider intelligent buying it all D: Every one of my mates knows the score now though. I tend to find once people find out the extent of it all, and think just a little into the matter (rather than just repeating the cultlike chant of 'transwomen are women'), they become 'gender critical'

The more Indias on TV insisting straight men should shag transwomen the better. Wakes more people up to the crazyness.

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 07:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamie89 (Post 9774651)
I know, I wasn't trying to make it sound like it's all about genitals lol, I was just responding to a comment about genitals. People can have whatever preferences they want though, and smells/touch/hair/body shape etc etc, all fine and I get it. The angle I was coming from was if somebody matched somebody else's preference in those ways or whatever way it might be, and they were attracted to them and wanted to date them, and the only thing that put them off was finding out they are trans, then although they're perfectly entitled to that, I just don't personally get why they would be.

Well i mean obviously people can change their preferences.Nothing wrong in that.
But also imo there’s nothing wrong in saying that you’re not attracted to trans people if you aren’t.
You can state that you would never date a trans person because that is how you genuinely feel.They don’t float your boat.
It’s just stating your sexuality.

-Sue- 06-01-2018 07:22 PM

This CBB season sure is an education

Crimson Dynamo 06-01-2018 07:25 PM

Its getting more and more like the "Im a Laydeeee sketch"

hijaxers 06-01-2018 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gusto Brunt (Post 9774416)
She's very arrogant.

India Willoughby in therapy gonna get shown in future for sure.

y.winter 06-01-2018 07:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774658)
I have learned much from you on this topic.
I’ve seen that Riley before on Youtube.He/she/they seems like they have alot of growing up to do.
This whole agenda seems to have gone from ‘we want acceptance’ to ‘we want to reshape the world around us and force you all to think,feel and be how we want or you’re an evil bigoted transphobe’

I agree. The entire video has a very passive aggressive subtext of "I won't tell you how to live your life, but it's wrong how you live your life and this is how you should think, feel and act".
Deconstructing emotions and sexual attraction like it's some sort of a technical issue that you can adjust - it's not practical nor making any sense.

Jamie89 06-01-2018 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774672)
Well i mean obviously people can change their preferences.Nothing wrong in that.
But also imo there’s nothing wrong in saying that you’re not attracted to trans people if you aren’t.
You can state that you would never date a trans person because that is how you genuinely feel.They don’t float your boat.
It’s just stating your sexuality.

That's all fair enough, I'm not trying to say there's anything 'wrong' with holding that view though just to be clear, I'm just saying I don't really get why someone would rule out ever being attracted to someone, that they otherwise would be attracted to, purely on the basis of them being trans, if the status of being trans was all it came down to (however rare that situation might be). I don't think it's a 'wrong' view to hold though.

edit to add: I don't think it's the same as stating a sexuality though is it? Like if I was attracted to a trans man/born female I would still consider myself gay. I think.

Crimson Dynamo 06-01-2018 07:32 PM

All of the TL's trans pals hate her and are going ballistic

JerseyWins 06-01-2018 07:32 PM

Yeah I take the other person's side in this India dispute yet again but India has not necessarily been bad TV for me. :joker:

smudgie 06-01-2018 07:37 PM

Depends on the context, how the discussion evolved etc.
If I was ginger, bald or wore glasses and somebody in the group decided to spout how they wouldn’t date a ginger, a baldy or a spectacle wearing person then I would think they were being rude. But just pass it off as their ignorance.
However if the conversation was brought up as the general subject and opinions asked for then that would be totally different.

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamie89 (Post 9774705)
That's all fair enough, I'm not trying to say there's anything 'wrong' with holding that view though just to be clear, I'm just saying I don't really get why someone would rule out ever being attracted to someone, that they otherwise would be attracted to, purely on the basis of them being trans, if the status of being trans was all it came down to (however rare that situation might be). I don't think it's a 'wrong' view to hold though.

edit to add: I don't think it's the same as stating a sexuality though is it? Like if I was attracted to a trans man/born female I would still consider myself gay. I think.

See i think differently and it’s probably unpopular on here but I believe that a man can never become a woman no matter how many ops and hormones they have.To me they’re still male so if i found myself have feelings for a trans woman i’d consider myself gay.

Monkey Slut 06-01-2018 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamie89 (Post 9774705)
That's all fair enough, I'm not trying to say there's anything 'wrong' with holding that view though just to be clear, I'm just saying I don't really get why someone would rule out ever being attracted to someone, that they otherwise would be attracted to, purely on the basis of them being trans, if the status of being trans was all it came down to (however rare that situation might be). I don't think it's a 'wrong' view to hold though.

edit to add: I don't think it's the same as stating a sexuality though is it? Like if I was attracted to a trans man/born female I would still consider myself gay. I think.

I think it comes down to other people's perceptions, honestly.

I don't it's the same either.

Jamie89 06-01-2018 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774746)
See i think differently and it’s probably unpopular on here but I believe that a man can never become a woman no matter how many ops and hormones they have.To me they’re still male so if i found myself have feelings for a trans woman i’d consider myself gay.

Yeah that is quite unpopular on here lol :p But no that actually makes sense in that case, I wouldn't have thought sexuality would come into it or it would make someone question their sexuality if that happened but I see what you're saying.

Vicky. 06-01-2018 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamie89 (Post 9774705)

edit to add: I don't think it's the same as stating a sexuality though is it? Like if I was attracted to a trans man/born female I would still consider myself gay. I think.

Your sexuality is your own business, but personally if I was shagging a pre-op transman I would consider myself bi as the transman is female. Post op...not sure, but its not the same as a man as its all surgically constructed (also SRS for transmen is nowhere near as avanced as SRS for transwomen) but fairly sure I would still see them as female, just with...male features or something.

I think I have mentioned my extended family member before but there is a similar situation going on pretty close to me at the moment. A family member is dating a transwoman, the transwoman wants srs but my family member says she is not a lesbian and wants a cock to shag, basically. So she considers herself in a straight relationship.

Its all a bit..confusing really.But however someone looks at it, sex is a valid reason to turn someone down. Sexuality is not something anyone needs to 'get over' or be considered transphobic tbh..that does imply sexuality is a choice.

bots 06-01-2018 07:45 PM

This is where lines have to be drawn. People are entitled to be as they want, in whatever sexual form they want, but they should give everyone else the same respect and allow everyone else the same freedom to be themselves and express themselves as they want. Forcing someone to like something they just don't is never going to end well

As I said in a previous thread she has set the cause back 20 years by her appearance on this show.

-Sue- 06-01-2018 07:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bitontheslide (Post 9774769)
This is where lines have to be drawn. People are entitled to be as they want, in whatever sexual form they want, but they should give everyone else the same respect and allow everyone else the same freedom to be themselves and express themselves as they want. Forcing someone to like something they just don't is never going to end well

As I said in a previous thread she has set the cause back 20 years by her appearance on this show.

well said :clap1:

Brillopad 06-01-2018 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jamie89 (Post 9774705)
That's all fair enough, I'm not trying to say there's anything 'wrong' with holding that view though just to be clear, I'm just saying I don't really get why someone would rule out ever being attracted to someone, that they otherwise would be attracted to, purely on the basis of them being trans, if the status of being trans was all it came down to (however rare that situation might be). I don't think it's a 'wrong' view to hold though.

edit to add: I don't think it's the same as stating a sexuality though is it? Like if I was attracted to a trans man/born female I would still consider myself gay. I think.

Sorry Jamie, no disrespect intended, but if I dated a man only to discover he had once been a woman I would struggle with that and believe I would not be able to get past it. It would be too uncomfortable for me. I think it would be a big deal for many people.

Monkey Slut 06-01-2018 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774746)
See i think differently and it’s probably unpopular on here but I believe that a man can never become a woman no matter how many ops and hormones they have.To me they’re still male so if i found myself have feelings for a trans woman i’d consider myself gay.

So...you're usually attracted to cis women and then find yourself having feelings for someone who identify as a woman and looks like a women but just so happens to be trans and despite not being attracted to cis males before or since, that makes you consider yourself to be gay? That doesn't make sense to me. Would you still consider yourself to be straight if you dated a trans man because they were assigned female at birth?

Vicky. 06-01-2018 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monkey Slut (Post 9774774)
So...you're usually attracted to cis women and then find yourself having feelings for someone who identify as a woman and looks like a women but just so happens to be trans and despite not being attracted to cis males before or since, that makes you consider yourself to be gay? That doesn't make sense to me. Would you still consider yourself to be straight if you dated a trans man because they were assigned female at birth?

This is such rubbish...noone is 'assigned' anything at birth. Sex is noted. Assigned makes out that its just random Harry Potter sorting hat crap like 'oh lets put this one in with the boy group...no reason why, just we have decided this one is male' when its obviously not.

Edit. Yes, intersex people exist, before you say this. But intersex is not trans. And intersex groups/people have repeatedly asked to be left out of trans conversations.

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Monkey Slut (Post 9774774)
So...you're usually attracted to cis women and then find yourself having feelings for someone who identify as a woman and looks like a women but just so happens to be trans and despite not being attracted to cis males before or since, that makes you consider yourself to be gay? That doesn't make sense to me. Would you still consider yourself to be straight if you dated a trans man because they were assigned female at birth?

Yep.Because to me they are still a woman.

I suppose it all comes down to your perception of trans people.My opinion is that it is impossible to fully transition.It can’t happen without some kind of distant future genetic engineering.

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 07:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bitontheslide (Post 9774769)
This is where lines have to be drawn. People are entitled to be as they want, in whatever sexual form they want, but they should give everyone else the same respect and allow everyone else the same freedom to be themselves and express themselves as they want. Forcing someone to like something they just don't is never going to end well

As I said in a previous thread she has set the cause back 20 years by her appearance on this show.

100%

This kind of thought police dictatorship thinking is a dangerous far left agenda which isn’t just limited to the trans issue.
It’s anti freedom of thought and freedom to even be who you are.It’s regressive af.

-Sue- 06-01-2018 07:58 PM

Nadia Almada & Luke Anderson the only 2 housemates I can remember were nothing like India.. they were so easygoing and we actually got to know them as people not just their transgender side of things..

Maru 06-01-2018 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vicky. (Post 9774420)
Well if we are honest, most times you can tell. Especially with transwomen. Transmen do tend to pass very well in a few cases but they still have vaginas, and if they do not, its still not a 'penis'

The likes of Blair White pass very well...male friends have said they do find Blair attractive facially and such but could not sleep with someone who has a penis, as they are not gay. Even with SRS, its not a 'vagina...its an inverted penis or bits of colon made into a hole. So its still different. So I definitely understand saying you could never go there sexually tbh. It does noone any favours to pretend neovaginas are actual vaginas.

Yeah Blaire White is definitely passing. :laugh: She hasn't had the surgery though, she opted to keep her original equipment because she didn't want to lose the ability to orgasm (very understandable)


Quote:

Originally Posted by Vicky. (Post 9774623)
Tends to only be applied to lesbians. Its not just transactivists, a lot of 'normal' transgender people are the same. Lesbians are transphobic bigots as penises on transwomen are female body parts and as such, its the vagina they want so they are vagina fetishists and need to get over their bigotry.

Sounds mental, but its actually fairly common these days. Literally every lesbians friend I have has had an experience with a person like this.



Watch this, if you have spare time. Its all absolutely bat****.

This video is such trash but a surprising amt of folk who exist out there think this way.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey (Post 9774658)
I have learned much from you on this topic.
I’ve seen that Riley before on Youtube.He/she/they seems like they have alot of growing up to do.
This whole agenda seems to have gone from ‘we want acceptance’ to ‘we want to reshape the world around us and force you all to think,feel and be how we want or you’re an evil bigoted transphobe’

Agreed, it's gone too far. Now it's all about making grandiose moral accusations and covering up their own prejudice with emotional arguments whose sole purpose is to dictate to others and bully them into accepting their premise. It's no different than any other prejudice if you really listen to the reasoning behind their views and see the cues. There are some darker elements hiding behind these views, because when you feel you're superior enough to dictate to the rest of the group how the world not only should but MUST operate in order to achieve "total acceptance"... it's too similar for me to the Scientology scam and trying to achieve "clear".

And many of the arguments have a very strong hierarchy to them. Your gender/racial label literally dictates how you are expected to be treated/perceived.. and there's nothing you can do to escape it for the rest of your life. It's a very sad and miserable POV.

Northern Monkey 06-01-2018 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maru (Post 9774795)
Yeah Blaire White is definitely passing. :laugh: She hasn't had the surgery though, she opted to keep her original equipment because she didn't want to lose the ability to orgasm (very understandable)




This video is such trash but a surprising amt of folk who exist out there think this way.



Agreed, it's gone too far. Now it's all about making grandiose moral accusations and covering up their own prejudice with emotional arguments whose sole purpose is to dictate to others and bully them into accepting their premise. It's no different than any other prejudice if you really listen to the reasoning behind their views and see the cues. There are some darker elements hiding behind these views, because when you feel you're superior enough to dictate to the rest of the group how the world not only should but MUST operate in order to achieve "total acceptance"... it's too similar for me to the Scientology scam and trying to achieve "clear".

And many of the arguments have a very strong hierarchy to them. Your gender/racial label literally dictates how you are expected to be treated/perceived.. and there's nothing you can do to escape it for the rest of your life. It's a very sad and miserable POV.

Yes exactly and it’s not limited to the trans issue.It comes from a place of
‘Oh so you’re comfortable with your gender/you’re white/you’re straight/you’re male?
Well you have privilege.We need to take some of that away to make things more equal’
You don’t have enough victimhood points so you’re bottom of the hierarchy.
Then comes the dictating and being called ‘white male patriarchal cis scum who perpetuates rape culture rah rah rah’
It’s all the same ****.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:29 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.