Funny how guys get grief from women for what is actually an absolutely ideal weight and totally natural. And is far better for doing real manual work and not playing with weight s in the gym. That is the shape all manual workers such as builders and miners used to be, before women started demanding men kill themselves with bulk. Probably 38/30/36 and around 10 stone 7..

If you want men to be large and have artificial muscle they will wind up dead before 70 with a heart attack. Your ideal is far more threatening to men's health than the supposed ideal woman's body which can lead to osteoporosis, which is actually also a pressure created by women on women in the fashion industry.

Leave John James alone.

ILoveJosie and i'm a girl i also don't think she's fat. xc

Same here! love her and think she looks great :)

It's better her looking like what she does than being really skinny making herself not eat much and stuff at long as she's happy that's all that matters.

All the poster said was that John James was too skinny for her. We hear the same kind of thing from men all the time, especially on here... and sometimes in very derogatory terms. And if now, after all these years, blokes are succumbing to the pressure of feeling they have to conform to an ideal, if they feel that their bodies are scrutinised and commented upon and everything they are is all about how they look... welcome to our world.

Personally I find John James too skinny too. I like a little meat on the bone.

There is absolutely no way JJ is remotely interested in her physically at all - she is just so not his type. He will be over the likes of Sophie Reade like a rash when he gets out and has finished with the mag deals.

Oh wow, I bow to your superior knowledge, you've obviously met every single woman in Britain and studied their bodies. Silly me :hugesmile:

I think the girls on Tibb just hate that JJ1 can love Josie.

what a lot of female dogs

wooof

Yeah but she's been really nice too John she's going to be really sad when he goes bk too Australia if he does. Aww i really like Josie though xxxxxxxxxxx

Yeah, a step too far there, I think.

No-one said JJ doesn't love Dozy - all boys love their mums.:wink:

you could be right

Well that may be the case in your part of the world, but I can assure you that down south she would be considered a lot bigger than average. If the average is a size 16 she is at least 2-3 sizes bigger than that.

Jealous of Josie!? LOL. As if...

What is there to be jealous of? A double chin and stomach rolls? No thank you.

I think your right, i am so jealous of someone who goes around picking other peoples noses.

can anyone explain why they do not like her without bringing in her size and looks,( in a reasonable way.?)

exactly

she is having a whale of a time


people need to open their thighs and see the wood from the tree trunks

the worst is when haters say he isn't attractive.

1 thing Josie isn't=ugly

That isn't my ideal either, was just pointing out that he isn't necessarily my type before typing the rest of the post since many of the JJ/Josie lovers seem to think that pulling the 'you're jealous because you fancy John James' get out of jail free card is enough to nullify any valid criticism made of them.

I have no clue what is going on with John and Josie, I suspect that John is working to a system he devised (as far as poss.) while doing all his research on BB, UK and Australia.
He told Josie 'If you knew the truth about me, you'd know that Im the same as Mario' ... this was a response to Josie saying that Mario gets wound up because he is desperate to stay in BB because he'd been trying to get in for 10 years.
I don't think Josie planned on a romance (but then who does for sure) but I do think she is very pretty ... as far as her size is concerned I think its hilarious that so many people feel free to criticise Josies weight from behind their curtain of privacy, wouldn't it be fun to see just how stick-thin (or otherwise) they are!(incidentally, I've always been between 7.4 and 8.10 .. altogether too skinny for my liking) I thought this Country was getting past those type of judgements, I think its all the more sad when grown women do it .. they should be ashamed of themselves!
Some Josie haters seem to revel in throwing all kinds of nasty accusations around about her .. the way she looks, her motives (re John) ... every aspect of the Girl they can think of, to Insult! They become abusive when challanged and assume that THEY 'know' (whats going on in Josies head and so on)...
It makes me feel like voting for Josie to win purely because so many have been so utterly vile about her, I really wish they would get some perspective wether they hate her or not, it would be really nice to have some of these 'adults' set an example instead of ranting and becoming abusive on topics they disagree with.

The reason people keep on about her size, is that she is so insistent that she is a size 16 when she is so blatantly NOT. We are not blind, and she HAS definitely put on quite a bit of weight in the house. The fact she is fat is not the point, it's the blatant denial of her fans, when she so clearly IS. JJ can barely hide his repulsion when she wants to be more intimate with him.

Personally I don't think how fat or thin a person has much to do with their personalities ordinarily, but in Josie's case her bone idleness and slothful ways are a major turn off and it is logical that people will associate her permanently horizontal state with her corresponding increase in girth.

What I am saying is that Josie is SO obviously not JJ's type, which according to his friends and his own mum, are stick thin model types. So what exactly IS he playing at, as if we didn't know?:rolleyes: Someone so obsessed with their own looks is usually equally vain about the looks of the girl on their arm.

As to Josie's "personality", she can at times make some funny comments, but mostly she is extremely boring, particularly when she spends so much time lying in bed, or slopping around the house wrapped in a duvet or sitting on the bench smoking herself silly. As for her thumbsucking, she barely gets away with it aged 25 years - just imagine her when she's 40 or 50 with her thumb still stuck in her gob - it's revolting to look at. I have not found her or JJ remotely interesting and if they had gone earlier in the show I would not have even noticed or cared.

I disliked her before John James feigned any interest in her.

Well you would know all about those, you being the king of self ownage.

As well as being a real bitch at times and being two-faced about the other hms, she is immature and acting like a teenager! It is embarrassing. At 25 with the job she has - she should have more to offer to the house than fawning over the token good-looker! She seems to want an easy ride!

It isn't about her size - but people cannot help but mention it at times when her lazy behaviour is clearly a factor in her being the size she is! It has more to do with a disapproval of her chosen lifestyle and resulting size, which is clearly self-induced - than about her size per se!

Why should people sympathise with her, when she feels sorry for herself and complains JJ wouldn't look at a girl like her - when she has chosen to be that way! Many other women who are slimer and look better, do so because they make more effort and work at it!

Shouldn't your question actually be - why should we like her? What has she done to deserve to be liked?

Not for 25 year-olds who havent had any children it isn't! And besides she is clearly bigger than a 16!

Wow, thanks for a reasoned argument. I can ofcorse see what you are saying and agree (not to mention chuckled) with most of the points you make.
She hasn't done herself any favours under that duvet and I'd agree she is being conservative about her dress size.
What I can't understand is the level of base, sometimes crude remarks levied at Josie, about every aspect of her character which are usually follwed up with worse, when people (sometimes youngsters) disagree ... its excessive and presumtive.
My take on the John/Josie matter, is that John is the leader .. I've never really had much time for Josie but I honestly think she just fell into it (JJJ)
In response to a post I made on the subject recently, one member insulted me, accusing me of being stupid etc ...so I deliberatly made pro-Josie comments (could have been anyone that particular member supported) in other threads, just to see(curious) how far this member would take things. Quite honestly, it was a disgrace .. this persons abusive, insulting remarks about Josie and to Josie supporters were the most degrading display of manners and decency I have seen for a long time.
Obviously, reading all the posts within several threads about Josie, I saw that there are lots of other really nasty, unessesary perceptions attributed to Josie and presented as Facts ... many were unfair and cruel.
In the main, as I have expalined ... I'm not a fan of Josie but I hate that kind of attitude.
Incidentally, I think you've summed Josie up ... its pretty much how I see her!

That is todays funny joke folks:joker::joker::joker::joker::joker::xyxwave:

I'm not jealous of Josie lol. I think John is good looking but I'm not jealous, it's not like I'm gonna get with him lol!!!! :laugh: