ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums
Page 4 of 7 « First 23 4 56 Last »
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

ThisisBigBrother.com - UK TV Forums (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/index.php)
-   BB8 (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=60)
-   -   It is not fair on Emily, Charley should be evicted for making that illegal comment to gerry [merged] (https://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forums/showthread.php?t=40114)

no1bigbrofan 22-07-2007 10:06 PM
i dont recon bb would ever kick charley out couse they love her for some reason

Matt 22-07-2007 10:08 PM
One comment got Emily ejected, without any warnings.

Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7

what made the race row even worse is fans that constantly complained about it and made a big deal about it.
In which case, I'm gonna keep complaining, and get everyone I know to do it too, in order to get Charley ejected...

Matt08 22-07-2007 10:11 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt
One comment got Emily ejected, without any warnings.

Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7

what made the race row even worse is fans that constantly complained about it and made a big deal about it.
In which case, I'm going to keep complaining, and get everyone I know to do it too, in order to get Charley ejected...
Then that's going to make the whole incident alot more worse. There's no point you wasting Channel 4 and Ofcom's time and money investigating a silly little incident. What Charley said is unfortunately part of everyday life and you need to deal with that Matt instead of making loads of un-nessesary complaints.

Billy 22-07-2007 10:12 PM
Sorry but Emily the great was FAR too good a housemate to kick out, whereas we have a rubbish one getting kept in

Matt 22-07-2007 10:13 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt
One comment got Emily ejected, without any warnings.

Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7

what made the race row even worse is fans that constantly complained about it and made a big deal about it.
In which case, I'm going to keep complaining, and get everyone I know to do it too, in order to get Charley ejected...
Then that's going to make the whole incident alot more worse. There's no point you wasting Channel 4 and Ofcom's time and money investigating a silly little incident. What Charley said is unfortunately part of everyday life and you need to deal with that Matt instead of making loads of un-nessesary complaints.
Tell that to the 50,000 people who complained about the race row...

Matt08 22-07-2007 10:13 PM
Maybe Emily should be let back in but I can't see the point in complaining about Charley, she want's attention and the complainers are just giving her more of it.

farhad 22-07-2007 10:16 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
I am confused as to why people are making complaints to C4 and Ofcom - the views and comments made were from Charleys infantile and unintelligent brain and not the views expressed by C4 nor BB - perhaps BB bosses should put disclaimers before each programme to state this fact.

The comment itself is perhaps slanderous or perhaps homophobic in the sense that the comment was made as an attack to Gerry's sexuality in which Gerry has the right to make an official complaint to the police. Maybe on this fact that 'kicking' out Charley would be the correct thing to do and complaints can be justified.

But as we all know Charley cannot have an intelligent argument and will always use the lowest common denominater and says the first thing that pops in her head - unfortunatley on this occasion she was insinuating that gerry is a 'paedophille' by sleeping with underage boys.

Gerry has admitted in past programme that he likes his men younger but does not suggest under-age.

I do feel that Bb producers etc may have been OTT with Emily and a stiff telling off would have been more appropriate rather than 'kicking' her out of the house but as the Shilpa Shetty vs Jade Goody situation was still fresh then they made a knee jerk reaction to please Ofcom and shareholders then maybe the viewers.
You are 100% wrong, this was Charley's comment;

He said to her that she was effectively calling him a paedophile and her response was "I don't care!"

She knew what she was saying and she didn't give a flying *****.

I can't believe Carole excused her... I can't believe BB excused her... and I can't believe people on here are excusing her.

It's disgusting.:conf:

Matt 22-07-2007 10:17 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7
Maybe Emily should be let back in but I can't see the point in complaining about Charley, she want's attention and the complainers are just giving her more of it.
The point of complaing about Charley is this:

Charley technically accused Gerry of being a paedophile, which is just as bad as Emily being ejected for saying just one racial slur, which in my opinion wasn't even racially intended.

If they ejected Emily for that, why not eject Charley for comitting a crime that was just as bad?

James 22-07-2007 10:19 PM
Another mass-complaint to Ofcom could finish Big Brother completely.

farhad 22-07-2007 10:21 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7
Maybe Emily should be let back in but I can't see the point in complaining about Charley, she want's attention and the complainers are just giving her more of it.
The point of complaing about Charley is this:

Charley technically accused Gerry of being a paedophile, which is just as bad as Emily being ejected for saying just one racial slur, which in my opinion wasn't even racially intended.

If they ejected Emily for that, why not eject Charley for comitting a crime that was just as bad?
Matt you forgot to mention the word Slander, Charley was being slanderous, which is a crime.

Matt08 22-07-2007 10:25 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by James
Another mass-complaint to Ofcom could finish Big Brother completely.
I definatly don't want to see Big Brother finish completely. Please don't complain!

Matt 22-07-2007 10:25 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Matt2k7
Quote:
Originally posted by James
Another mass-complaint to Ofcom could finish Big Brother completely.
I definatly don't want to see Big Brother finish completely. Please don't complain!
Too late :thumbs:

Matt08 22-07-2007 10:28 PM
I doubt many people will complain anyway, because most people have better things to do. I doubt that not many more than 100 people will complain.

Noel 22-07-2007 10:39 PM
If we all complain, will Ofcom force Endemol to kick Charley out?

Feral 22-07-2007 10:40 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by farhad
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
I am confused as to why people are making complaints to C4 and Ofcom - the views and comments made were from Charleys infantile and unintelligent brain and not the views expressed by C4 nor BB - perhaps BB bosses should put disclaimers before each programme to state this fact.

The comment itself is perhaps slanderous or perhaps homophobic in the sense that the comment was made as an attack to Gerry's sexuality in which Gerry has the right to make an official complaint to the police. Maybe on this fact that 'kicking' out Charley would be the correct thing to do and complaints can be justified.

But as we all know Charley cannot have an intelligent argument and will always use the lowest common denominater and says the first thing that pops in her head - unfortunatley on this occasion she was insinuating that gerry is a 'paedophille' by sleeping with underage boys.

Gerry has admitted in past programme that he likes his men younger but does not suggest under-age.

I do feel that Bb producers etc may have been OTT with Emily and a stiff telling off would have been more appropriate rather than 'kicking' her out of the house but as the Shilpa Shetty vs Jade Goody situation was still fresh then they made a knee jerk reaction to please Ofcom and shareholders then maybe the viewers.
You are 100% wrong, this was Charley's comment;

He said to her that she was effectively calling him a paedophile and her response was "I don't care!"

She knew what she was saying and she didn't give a flying ****.

I can't believe Carole excused her... I can't believe BB excused her... and I can't believe people on here are excusing her.

It's disgusting.:conf:
Please elaborate on what comment/opinion is 100% wrong??!!!

Also I am not excusing anything.

I just do not understand where the complaint actually lies!!! All we witnessed was an argument between two people jousting insults at one another - just unfortunate that an insult insinuated that one person was a paedophille wishing to sleep with under age boys which in fact turned out to be untrue.

Course she didin't give a flying *******!!! She was berating the man and she did not have the instant intelligence nor nobility to apolgise for such a comment till the BB voice told her that her comment may be construed as offensive and cause distress.

I will complain to Ofcom and C4 when I feel it deems appropriate and have nothing better to do with my time.

farhad 22-07-2007 10:44 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
Quote:
Originally posted by farhad
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
I am confused as to why people are making complaints to C4 and Ofcom - the views and comments made were from Charleys infantile and unintelligent brain and not the views expressed by C4 nor BB - perhaps BB bosses should put disclaimers before each programme to state this fact.

The comment itself is perhaps slanderous or perhaps homophobic in the sense that the comment was made as an attack to Gerry's sexuality in which Gerry has the right to make an official complaint to the police. Maybe on this fact that 'kicking' out Charley would be the correct thing to do and complaints can be justified.

But as we all know Charley cannot have an intelligent argument and will always use the lowest common denominater and says the first thing that pops in her head - unfortunatley on this occasion she was insinuating that gerry is a 'paedophille' by sleeping with underage boys.

Gerry has admitted in past programme that he likes his men younger but does not suggest under-age.

I do feel that Bb producers etc may have been OTT with Emily and a stiff telling off would have been more appropriate rather than 'kicking' her out of the house but as the Shilpa Shetty vs Jade Goody situation was still fresh then they made a knee jerk reaction to please Ofcom and shareholders then maybe the viewers.
You are 100% wrong, this was Charley's comment;

He said to her that she was effectively calling him a paedophile and her response was "I don't care!"

She knew what she was saying and she didn't give a flying ****.

I can't believe Carole excused her... I can't believe BB excused her... and I can't believe people on here are excusing her.

It's disgusting.:conf:
Please elaborate on what comment is 100% wrong??!!!

Also I am not excusing anything.

I just do not understand where the complaint actually lies!!! All we witnessed was an argument between two people jousting insults at one another - just unfortunate that an insult insinuated that one person was a paedophille wishing to sleep with under age boys which in fact turned out to be untrue.

Course she didin't give a flying *******!!! She was berating the man and she did not have the instant intelligence nor nobility to apolgise for such a comment till the BB voice told her that her comment may be construed as offensive an cause ditress.

I will complain to Ofcom and C4 when I feel it deems appropriate and have nothing better to do with my time.
Your argument was that Charley did not meant what she said, she was unintelligent and unaware what she was saying, but she was aware what she was saying, she said "I dont care", when Gerry told her she is calling him a peadophile.

Juelz 22-07-2007 10:48 PM
you people are absoloute idiots.

the people who complain are sad and pathetic.

she didnt say anything bad about it, it didnt offend anyone

just shut up.

James 22-07-2007 10:50 PM
Admin message: It's against the rules of the forum to attack other posters for the views the hold. :nono:

Big Brother warned her about her behaviour. They dealt with it.

James 22-07-2007 10:52 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Juelz
you people are absoloute idiots.

the people who complain are sad and pathetic.

she didnt say anything bad about it, it didnt offend anyone

just shut up.
And that is out of order that post. Read the forum rules.

Juelz 22-07-2007 10:52 PM
^what a stupid rule
who cares its called a forum we should be allowed to do that^

Feral 22-07-2007 10:53 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by farhad
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
Quote:
Originally posted by farhad
Quote:
Originally posted by Feral
I am confused as to why people are making complaints to C4 and Ofcom - the views and comments made were from Charleys infantile and unintelligent brain and not the views expressed by C4 nor BB - perhaps BB bosses should put disclaimers before each programme to state this fact.

The comment itself is perhaps slanderous or perhaps homophobic in the sense that the comment was made as an attack to Gerry's sexuality in which Gerry has the right to make an official complaint to the police. Maybe on this fact that 'kicking' out Charley would be the correct thing to do and complaints can be justified.

But as we all know Charley cannot have an intelligent argument and will always use the lowest common denominater and says the first thing that pops in her head - unfortunatley on this occasion she was insinuating that gerry is a 'paedophille' by sleeping with underage boys.

Gerry has admitted in past programme that he likes his men younger but does not suggest under-age.

I do feel that Bb producers etc may have been OTT with Emily and a stiff telling off would have been more appropriate rather than 'kicking' her out of the house but as the Shilpa Shetty vs Jade Goody situation was still fresh then they made a knee jerk reaction to please Ofcom and shareholders then maybe the viewers.
You are 100% wrong, this was Charley's comment;

He said to her that she was effectively calling him a paedophile and her response was "I don't care!"

She knew what she was saying and she didn't give a flying ****.

I can't believe Carole excused her... I can't believe BB excused her... and I can't believe people on here are excusing her.

It's disgusting.:conf:
Please elaborate on what comment is 100% wrong??!!!

Also I am not excusing anything.

I just do not understand where the complaint actually lies!!! All we witnessed was an argument between two people jousting insults at one another - just unfortunate that an insult insinuated that one person was a paedophille wishing to sleep with under age boys which in fact turned out to be untrue.

Course she didin't give a flying *******!!! She was berating the man and she did not have the instant intelligence nor nobility to apolgise for such a comment till the BB voice told her that her comment may be construed as offensive an cause ditress.

I will complain to Ofcom and C4 when I feel it deems appropriate and have nothing better to do with my time.
Your argument was that Charley did not meant what she said, she was unintelligent and unaware what she was saying, but she was aware what she was saying, she said "I dont care", when Gerry told her she is calling him a peadophile.
No I did not!!! Are you reading it correctly???!!!

Not once in any of the posts did I say that she did not mean what she said nor that she was unaware on what she was saying. In fact I had suggested that she is not of the intelligence to have a proper argument stating facts but has little intelligence therefore accusing Gerry of being a 'paedo' rather than having anything constructive to say.

Saying she didn't care meant (well what I percived it as) that she said something offensive with all it's intentions and did not care if it offended. Saying 'I don't care' does not state that she was unaware.

James 22-07-2007 10:56 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Juelz
^what a stupid rule
who cares its called a forum we should be allowed to do that^
Quote:
1. Treat other forum members with respect, no insults. *Important*
http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru...age=forumrules


Quote:

Please pay particular attention to what it says above about insulting or disrespecting other forum members. This even includes calling another member, for example, 'an idiot' or 'a fool'. Dismissing another post by saying something like 'that's complete rubbish' counts as not treating a forum member's opinion with respect. If you disagree with a post it would be better to explain why you disagree. Don't automatically assume because you disagree with someone's viewpoint that it is wrong.

Insulting posts are simply not allowed and these type of posts will be edited or deleted from now on and more warnings will issued.
http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru....php?tid=57823

Juelz 22-07-2007 10:57 PM
i didn't deny that they were the rules, jimmy.

i merely pointed out the insignificance of said rules.

lovelyg 22-07-2007 10:58 PM
Do we really want Charley to suffer the suffering that Jade Goody and Jo from S-Club 7 suffered?

I wouldn't want her to, she's a loud mouth biatch who has said the wrong thing, but she doesn't deserve that x

James 22-07-2007 11:01 PM
Quote:
Originally posted by Juelz
i didn't deny that they were the rules, jimmy.

i merely pointed out the insignificance of said rules.
:rolleyes: I can assure you they are very significant. Unless you want to be banned from posting.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:05 PM.
Page 4 of 7 « First 23 4 56 Last »
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.