Dupin, yesterday you were telling RetroMan off for trying to analyze your personality, so stop doing it to us

That's not analysing your personality, it's stating the obvious.

Ditto. I feel exactly the same. Afterall, we all have to remember that it is a singing contest.

Although what she did was stupid, it was a few years ago, and we all make mistakes. It's not for us to judge her. We can only judge her singing and thats it. What she does in her personal life is no business of ours. We should respect her decision to do what she wants. We wouldn't like people telling us what to do, so we shouldn't expect Emily to.

Fantastic post, Noel. You took the words from my mouth LOL.

Who wnats to bet we get:

"Ive already judged her singing, and to be honest its dreadful"
from King Dupin

Lol. Let's stop argueing and feel the love!
#Can you feel the love tonight?#

I sounded very hippyish there..lol.

Lol. Thanx!
Do ya want them back?
It'll cost ya. =D lol.

Don't you have some self-pitying to get on with?

Anyway, I'm all for the fact that anyone who subjects themsevles to these programmes basically allows the whole public to judge them, so I think it's every right for any of us to give our opinion on it. Like I said earlier, we're allowed to judge the fact she nearly died, so we're allowed to judge anything else to do with her private live, I think.

Can't you just handle the fact he doesn't like her?

I think he can, but he just doesn't like the fact that her personal life is getting into it all.

Well that is what this thread is about...:conf:

But why shouldn't it? We're allowed to judge it, it's not like I liked her before and let this change my opinion.

She seemed like a stubborn little girl before, and this just reinforces it. I think it's ridiculous to claim that we have to completely judge everything on their voices.

#Coombya my Lord...Coombya.#

It's Kum Ba Yah, I think. ;)

Lol. Watever! The message is still there..