Quote:
Originally Posted by James
(Post 3886178)
I think it is pretty much fine. Just checked there and saw that Claymores has 36 previous infractions and warnings. I'd guess on many forums someone with that record would be banned a fair while ago. We are pretty lenient here really.
If people are leaving it is not because of overly-harsh or unfair moderating, more likely people not sticking to the rules and causing arguments.
|
Try looking into the reasons for the infractions, 8 because he winged about a certain permanently banned member being allowed back, surely a private word from a mod, explaining the situation would have cleared up that up without the need for a harsh punishment?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dezzy
(Post 3886188)
That reason doesn't fly with me, if you want an audience it's because you want drama. If you want to talk to us we're always here, we're not monsters.
|
Yeah whenever anyone complains about moderating decisions even if they have PM'ed staff with or without receiving a reply they are pretty much automatically infracted for causing drama, its a good coverall.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ~Kerry~
(Post 3886189)
Perhaps if you also stop the 'you and us' mentality people will respect you more? Sorry but Mods are no better than users
|
Nah they wont stop the them or us mentality as they look down on us pondlife from TiBB towers.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dezzy
(Post 3886193)
If I've got a mentality it's because it's been installed in me by hostility from other members. I always try to be warm and friendly and ultimately if people bother to talk to me in PM, Also I don't wear my mod hat all the tiem and I regurlarly post in the forum, if I had such a mentality I wouldn't be able to intergrate as well as I do surely?
|
Its a question of having dealt with drama putting it to the side and moving on, life is exactly the same, you will become embittered if you always dwell on past battles and view everyone with suspicion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dezzy
(Post 3886202)
11 infractions are a lot, it's not surprising he's on a week long ban.
|
Look at the circumstances of those infractions.
What else can people do if they cant see Mods active on the forum? They know some mods are there but because the mods are "invisible" ro non staff they cant PM so they get fustrated and feel they have to post on the forum.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dezzy
(Post 3886205)
I might be misreading the forum but I find it to be much more relaxed in the last few days and we don't get nearly as many reports as we used to. I think it's just a minority of members causing the tension really. If i'm honest I've never known Tibb to feel this friendly, usually you have cliques going off at each other and endless arguments but that's not the case. It's a situation where the loud minority are overpowering the quiet majority.
|
Yes I think you are misreading the forum, there may be less of those you view as troublemakers posting on the forums. The cliques are still there, it may just be because one of the group of cliques has staff as members.
Lets face it there were members on here accusing another member of what is classed as an international crime, yet mods just stood by and watched, yes I know the member was warned he even posted how he had only been warned. Just like a couple of nights ago another member even stated that people had deliberately ganged up against someone who recently copped for a ban.
Funny how that comment and a few others were deleted, but not by the member posting it, aint it. Of course there is no conspiracy but lets face it staff here dont like to be questioed or challenged on their decisions do they, thats at least an infraction isnt it?