She basically had her family around...everyone else probably came round when johnny was out of town.

She was taunting him. Not something someone who is terrified would do :suspect:

She accused Johnny of cheating. While she was the one cheating.

Again, abuse victims will taunt their abuser.

That's a fact

You would be happy with your partner secretly filming you banging your kitchen up ,and getting drunk ???. What if she posted it online? .

Actually I already said several times that it's obvious AH was drunk as a skunk in some of the audio's,she sounds wasted / slurry . But it seems ok for her to take drugs & get drunk by looks of it? .

If she's so frightened of JD ,why did she slap him in his ear & repeatedly hit him & throw things at him ,she also pulled his hair. She's thrown that many hands.

While hitting them. That makes Amber the abuser.

Of course it's perfectly acceptable for Amber to do drugs and hit Johnny. After all, she's a woman and they're allowed to punch who they want :bored:

whilst being as 'terrified' as she claimed she was ?? , But I thought you said JD was 'controlling' :whistle:. Why would a victim taunt their abuser unless they had a death wish :conf:.

this case isnt about that.:shrug:

By not allowing her to film in the house, by grabbing and attempting to smash her phone when she does film in the house...well that kind of proves he is controlling.

Maybe Johnny’s next victim while he off his face on drink and drugs will be a good girl and stay in the bedroom.

Women in this thread making excuses for him should be ashamed of yourselves.

By claiming he got her her movie parts, that's also very controlling.

Exactly, I think people believe that it's a "whose side are you on/who is worse" trial? I don't think people realise that it's actually possible to be generally on Depp's side and STILL accept that Heard did not commit libel.

My main concern is that it's a bloody trial-by jury i.e. a bunch of laypeople, so I'm not convinced the jury will fully understand either.

No one is making excuses for him. Hes definitely not an angel in all this.
But I don't believe he ever hit Amber.
Amber hit Johnny and this is a fact.

He did help to get her the Aquaman role.

Again...you have taken jds word as gospel.

No he never stopped her filming in general . The reason he was upset/ distressed ,was because she was filming him without his permission & he was obviously not happy that day , we never actually see what happened before she started recording.

And she placed the phone on the counter , so he could easily grab it . That was more like her stopping him from grabbing it . She also lies to him when he confronts her about the filming. And he never actually took the phone off her, she still has it in her hand when the video ends.

She exploited his addiction , issues & sent the video to TMZ to make him look like a violent thug. Funny how she edited the video though but ok . And she denies the video came from her, despite us all seeing her filming him . If she's documenting 'proof' then why does she lie about the copyright & TMZ ? .

Both JD & Camille have said he's not perfect & he's no saint,but he would not bring this trial out in the open on TV if he was a woman beater . Like Camille said .. his most private & embarrassing moments are out there, especially with the texts & his words. But he never once mentions assaulting or abusing AH .

KM testifying that he NEVER pushed her down the stairs once again clarifies alot of hearsay BS , She's a very private person yet she came forward to clear things up. Which speaks volumes.

I mean I'd like to think I wouldn't be drunk and banging up the kitchen in the first place.......

wow.

Missing the point , what if you were still in a state of vulnerability or lost your temper .Or had an emotional breakdown.... and your loved one secretly filmed it like it was perfectly 'fine' ? . And to top it off they posted it online for people to see .

He was stinking drunk not having an emotional breakdown ffs. The excuses people are making for this guy, jesus. A State of vulnerability, what people do you know behave like that when they're "vulnerable" ?

Do you think it's ok to film someone drunk?. But we know that JD does have addiction problems & mental health issues , and he lost his mother around the same time of that video aswell i think.

It's actually a common thing for people living with someone who has issues with drink to film them while drunk to show them when they're sober what they become like, have you never heard that before? So yes If I were living with an alcoholic and they became violent/abusive while drunk I absolutely think it's OK to film them while drunk. I'm willing to bet if it was some average joe from the council estate filmed drunk and banging up his kitchen no one would call him "vulnerable" either

But why did she send the video to TMZ , and then lie about doing that.

As for the 'average joe' argument, if the video was posted online without his consent then that would be exploitive.