Like Rufus said on Xfactor; its better to have a few fans that are passionate about you than everybody thinking youre good but...meh.

Katie attracts those few passionate fans and they can get you far in this business.

I was making the point that not "all publicity is good publicity". Katie's press has been negative. Just because they're writing about you in the papers it doesn't mean that it's going to help make you popular. That's where I was going with that, as I think you probably know.

It wont end there.

This. I completely agreed with him when he said that.

Won't help her record sales and concert tickets though. When she goes back to working in the hairdresser's maybe they can all go along and admire her there. There are probably enough chairs in reception for all of them.

Of course not, the low-rate tabloids have got to have some bullsh!t to fill their papers with for the next week :sleep:

He committed one of the worst crimes possible though... so he is obviously going to get bad publicity, Katie has done nothing much of note to get bad publicity but she gets it anyway because they know people want to hear about her and it will sell unlike most the others on the show

Yeah, I refer you to my previous explanation. I genuinely thought you would understand the loose analogy. It's quite simple really.

Any Publicity is good... it keeps you in the public eye.. the publicity from this won't harm her it will probably gain her more votes from her fans next week actually

Not all publicity is good publicity and it's naive to think so. Careers can be ruined by the press. Bad publicity colours people's judgement. I understand you like her, and that's fine. However, she is not popular generally.

Not yet anyway but she will be very very soon :)

what 4 people lol?

LOL... You're a 'glass half full' kind of person. I kind of like that.

How many times have i told you katie haters but every week you never seem to get it sometimes i swear it is like talking to a brick wall :bored:

but we are not wrong as she more than likely came bottom of the votes this week,and before you say anything,howcome the bottom 3 mysteriously changed to a bottom 2? and why did it go to cheryl second to make a decision on who done better in the sing off? i think it was because katie was bottom of the votes.

You have been wrong every week so far you all think she is going to go every week but she always hangs on because she is Amazing... the bottom 3 changed to the bottom 2 because they stopped doing double eliminations.... and who cares about that now nothing is going to change what has happened Katie is through and TreyC is going home.

it was meant to be a bottom 3 this week,and i wouldnt be so bothered if it was 3 times in the bottom 2 each but it wasnt.

That was just a rumour a double eviction was never confirmed this week at all

it was confirmed.

No it wasn't it was bull****..

Well as I said before we know at least one of the acts who will be in the bottom 2 or 3 next week,Katie again for the 4th time, as the public will be livid that Katie was saved again and the way she was saved too. Even after a terrible sing off performance.

The girl is simply awful and the poublic overall clearly don't like her at all unless she sings Jungle Book songs.

Simon is losing a lot of credibility this year - imagine if this was Americcan Idol and the Judges saved a contestant who forgot their words and didn't perform well - he wouldn't dare there but feels its ok on the x factor.......

As much as i think they wouldn't dare.....you never know - their excuse will be -oh katie gave the strongest performance and based on that she should stay.....

Not Dermot's fault. It will be the producer in his ear ;)

Well let's see what happens next week. Katie is in trouble next week if she is in the bottom 2 with ANYONE except Wagner.

9 acts left. 8 can only go on tour. They will be all sh!tting themselves.

I predict Wagner will perform 1st next week too!

Yeah I think there is more contrived drama in this that we know and more voting 'for' future drama.

Treyc is the better singer. In fact, one of the best singers in the competition. She is a league above Kaitie,
HOWEVER...
...Katie is a mediocre singer yet has some kind of odd low-level lovey-hatey thing with the audience, stirs low-level press scandals and can develop into this anti-hero bad-girl and maybe even 'lovable loser' character for a few more weeks.

Treyc was one of my favourites but I could totally understand how she just failed to connect in any sort of way.