It's hard for me to vote because all of them are amazing :love:

but Beyoncé should win it, check up on it/ring the alarm/halo/put a ring on it/partition> careers

YOU TAKE THAT BACK... YOU TAKE THAT BACK RIGHT NOW?

-loads machine gun-

I dont think thats live :s

sang it mama

khia sings live

better than Beatles/Diana/Jacksons/Etta etc

Says the leader of the BS Thread :S

Slay those live vocals gorl

Beyoncé - 70 -
Britney Spears - 140 +
Lady GaGa - 70
-------------------------
4th Lily Allen
5th Pink
6th Rihanna
7th Gwen Stefani
8th Nicki Minaj
9th Cher Lloyd
10th Khia
11th Madonna
12th Whitney Houston
13th Shakira
14th Katy Perry
15th Lil' Kim
16th Cher
17th Azealia Banks
18th Avril Lavigne
19th Miley Syrup
20th Rita Ora
21st Keyshia Cole

Beyoncé - 80 +
Britney Spears - 130 -
Lady GaGa - 70
-------------------------
4th Lily Allen
5th Pink
6th Rihanna
7th Gwen Stefani
8th Nicki Minaj
9th Cher Lloyd
10th Khia
11th Madonna
12th Whitney Houston
13th Shakira
14th Katy Perry
15th Lil' Kim
16th Cher
17th Azealia Banks
18th Avril Lavigne
19th Miley Syrup
20th Rita Ora
21st Keyshia Cole
__________________

Yeah objectively Beyonce and Gaga are phenomenal singers, great dancers, they put a lot into their careers and are obviously well loved and respected as a result. And yet despite all of that... despite being leagues ahead of Britney in terms of vocal abilities, Britney just has that special something about her that you can't learn or teach, it's just that (cliche coming up) x factor that some people are born with that makes them stand out head and shoulders above the rest. She was such an engaging performer to watch, her voice is so instantly recognisable the second she opens her mouth to sing (well, lip sync nowadays) and everything. I mean I'm not a gigantic fan of her by any means but in terms of this, for me she's the clear winner.

:lovedup:

the true queen

look

everyone shut up

britney is talentless but had some good songs

gaga is a good writer and performer but she's also a pretentious bitch and has waned a lot

beyonce is the clear winner

now let's move on

That dancing is like a 6/10, she was bad for so long, she's just improved a bit and people think she's back to being brilliant, she's not, she's just better than she was in 07/08

and like saph said, i don't think thats live, probably just prerecorded vocals

Beyoncé - 70 -
Britney Spears - 140 +
Lady GaGa - 70
-------------------------
4th Lily Allen
5th Pink
6th Rihanna
7th Gwen Stefani
8th Nicki Minaj
9th Cher Lloyd
10th Khia
11th Madonna
12th Whitney Houston
13th Shakira
14th Katy Perry
15th Lil' Kim
16th Cher
17th Azealia Banks
18th Avril Lavigne
19th Miley Syrup
20th Rita Ora
21st Keyshia Cole

Beyoncé live > Britney live

How dare you come for the goddess of love, galaxy space and time like that

shame on you

:hmph: she's clearly top five material, just off the back of TFM alone, but she's no bey

no idc who wins out of those two :laugh: but britney is just a trailer girl who got lucky

I have to say Gaga is a flawless live performer

But who's winning this game :umm2:

You can't just call Gaga pretentious (which she totally is, soz Smithy) and then act like Beyonce isn't the most perfectly manicured to the point of obsessive compulsive passive aggressive scary Stepford Wives-esque PR relations; that's just as mental as Gaga IMO

this made me believe in jesus

not sure why I said PR relations when the R stands for relations