Paloma Faith would be good, she's a good personality, works well in front of audiences and would be different enough from Cheryl Cole to justify her presence on the panel. The more I think about it the more sense it makes, and it would give her music the platform it deserves.

Yes out of all the names, Paloma is my real want now. But I'd take Fergie too. I just want them to reveal it now, I swear the proper auditions are in late May, so they can't be far from a reveal.

no Paloma please, don't even know the flop ass bitch

get Fergie

Paloma's funny, I don't feel like Fergie would add anything that Cheryl doesn't currently offer. Fergie's not even really doing anything right now and hasn't been for years, I get the impression the other Peas are just waiting for them to get back together.

Legend Kesha Rose's name looking out of place in the title with flops like Mel B and Laura Whitmore

I'd like Ashley Roberts she really has nothing going on now she needs to promote her career she has a great personality and is gorgeous. Yeah she isn't exactly a big name but this could be really good for her!

mel b a flop http://s27.postimg.org/9xibs0twv/454...che=1393022528

Yeah when Mel b was a guest judge a couple of years ago she was no fun at all. She would get so boring! I think Paloma faith would be better on the voice

Queen Melaine has her experience tho :/

Paloma faith denies X factor rumours

http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the...s-rumours.html

Yeah but Victoria beckham has same amount doesn't mean she would be good. Actually did she do american idol once? :joker:

I think mel b was a judge on america's got talent.

I hope to god that this isn't true

Mel b was also a judge on Australia X factor and is currently a coach on the voice kids in Oz

Yeah Mel b has judged a few things. I was on about Victoria beckham. She once judged american idol and she was worse than Britney was on X factor us haha. Simon once wanted Victoria for X factor. I swear if she ever does get picked as a judge I wouldn't watch it again!

britney slayed the X factor
http://cdn02.cdnwp.celebuzz.com/wp-c...2/14/url-1.gif

All the spice girls are dusty has beens, none of them as a judge ty

Victoria's never been a judge on Idol that I know of?

Now Melanie C would be an excellent judge.

She did a stint as a guest judge on the 9th season auditions but she was awful

Looks like it's going to be mel b


http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the...lion-deal.html

I wouldn't mind Mel, she was quite good during her guest stint a few years back.

Yeah at least mel has got personality. I would rather have mel over someone like Rita Ora

Please not Mel b!!! I reckon Alesha Dixon or Ashley Roberts would be a good call! And if Alesha does end up as an X factor judge then Ashley Roberts or Michelle Keegan would make good replacements on BGT mmmm haha

There's a rumour going around that this is going be the panel this year.

Tinie(Tempah)-Mel B-Cheryl-Simon