Why is there so much insulting going on in here? :idc:

There wouldn't be anything obvious that made it look like the site was pay to use all it would be is either a donation button or a subscription option on the user cp.

these excuses are just going to far now

ummmm answer plz

only on tibb would there be meltdowns about members getting a few extra perks because they donate some money :umm2:

:joker::joker: got to keep the momentum going Jordan,

I don't understand why this is being met with OTT criticism.

No Sam we cant change your vote.

Right seriously take the arguments to pm or just drop it, other members are trying to have a genuine discussion and some are trying too hard to troll.

that's other thing that needs to be added then

My only concerns are elitism and if there was a separate section for VIP members

Also can I just say, the majority of forums wouldn't have discussions about these things.

If they wanted to bring in a new premium feature they would implement it regardless, and if members wanted it they would donate, if the didn't then they wouldn't. It's as simple as that.

Having premium donations wouldn't dismiss members from anything they currently have, it would just allow those who donate benefits for doing so.

If you want to implement a tiered system Tom feel free to run your own forum. Until then your going to have to accept that not everybody shares the same view as you and it might be beneficial for your side of the debate if you cut back on the mud slinging.

Why not just donations though?

this

Because like it or not, most people do things to get something in return. It's the way the world works.

TheStudentRoom is one of the largest forums in the UK.. it has it's own headquarters with paid staff and is meant to be a source for learning. If such an official and sensible forum like that sees no problem with having a subscription option (with the features I suggested in the OP like coloured usernames and a private section) I don't understand why it'd a problem on a big brother forum :crazy:

The only problem would be that old people don't like change. Yes, I said it.

This tbh

I'm against a private section. Sorry

what's TheStudentroom

Now this idea I could certainly get behind :p

There isn't going to be a private section

Wtf? :laugh:

This was only the real negative part of the ideas section but it doesn't look like something like this would be included anyway so my views have changed a bit, Wouldn't be against having a donations section and some kind of rewards in return for members.. coloured names etc.

would there be another way to donate then Paypal

Good

I don't mind the other features so much but I think the whole thing is a bit silly. If people get that excited over a coloured name... Just have a donations page that allows people to contribute without pressure and with anonymity

Now you have got that off your chest i hope you feel you can contribute

I quite like the idea of premium features, yes. It would be a good way to help fund the site. There's a few things we could do - some other things also I can think of that haven't been suggested here.

It could happen at some stage. :)

Contribute to what? :joker:

This (plus the word VIP, think 'subscriber' (think Josy suggested it a few pages back) would be better).

What? :laugh:

cant see what age has to do with it,a few young ones in here have said they are opposed from what I've seen

I'll have you know that the hour or so that james changed our names to rainbow on april fools day a year or so ago was an amazing and magical time that I shall never forget :hmph:

Yeah, I think Subscriber or Contributor would be a better thing to call someone who donates.

They are not overreacting though. :hugesmile:

:umm2:

Yes but would it be so special if it was the norm?
The novelty would wear off after you've subscribed so you may as well donate as and when you like.

Writing off all premier features is a bit incendiary but I think without care it could alienate people

I smell nachos and Guacamole and now i want nachos and guacamole. /relevant

Other things? :amazed:

Really? :joker::joker: