I dont know why but I'm leaning toward James Cordon as monster

I know think Tree is Jermaine Jenas

Really?! For me that performance actually kind of sealed it as Barrowman! It sounds like him, and the clues lead to it. A lot of people who’ve seen him live before have said it sounds like him too!

Unicorn is definitely John Barrowman, i have tons of his music on my laptop

so i know better than you probably

and i don't know who justin hawkins even is, not a A-lister celeb anyway

Yeah MB, Nicky, who thinks Idina Menzel, Yoko Ono and Brian May are on the show, knows better than you.

He thinks WHAT :joker:

from all of those, i am sure of Idina being the octopus :love:


Yoko was more because of the fox's bad vocals :laugh:


the Hedgehog, well if not brian, i think it's someone else quite old in his 70's

Idina Menzel is NOT on the show

The Fox was one of the best that night :skull:

I agree, I loved the entire performance

i know Idina's voice, since i heard defying gravity, let it go a million times

and i am fully confident it is her

what, ''one of the best'' LOL i didn't even hear what exactly she sang :laugh3: good that the title said blondie call me but i didn't hear that back in her singing

First of all, everyone has heard Defying Gravity and Let it Go a million times. Second: What the hell, Call Me is one of my favourite songs of all time and I didn't have anything to nitpick about the performance. Octopus was good but the persona felt a bit fake whereas I felt Fox connected more with everyone.

:laugh2: yep the fox is Samantha fox, same awful vocals there as the fox did call me :laugh2:

This is why you should actually watch the shows you talk about on here instead of just pretending to because you clearly have no idea what you’re talking about

They barely sound alike :skull:

It was NOT awful. I like Idina, just be realistic, she wouldn't do a show like this, she has a brilliant career at the moment. You don't have to be rude about the rest of the acts just because you want it to be her.

uh why not, other high profile stars like Seal, Donny Osmond did the US version :shrug:


i'm not rude, and the fox might impress me next time with a better song choice who knows

Seal and Donny Osmond are nowhere near the level of current popularity that Idina has, it's not realistic, Nicky.

Put it this way, Indina has much better things to be doing with her time than appearing on a brand new UK TV show dressed as an Octopus competing against the former Home Secretary and Bianca off EastEnders.

Idina Menzel, Yoko Ono, Brian May

:laugh2:

yep laugh, but i cannot be right all the time anyway


the peacock had me fooled too on US, i first had David Hasselhoff in mind, not Donny Osmond, but later on i switched to Donny

It's not about being right, it's about being realistic and not silly

How on earth does the Fox's VT in anyway relate to Yoko Ono?

Nobody is laughing at you, a lot of our guesses will be wrong, you don't have to stick with one single guess. One of the fun things about the show is that we can work together with other people to try find out who is behind the masks. There's nothing wrong with changing your mind about who one of them is, you won't lose anything.

I reckon the Tree is Judi Dench.

I’m laughing :joker: