Was TreyC better last year?
 

Or was it just that song?

she is nae use

creep (this year) was my fave performance so far

She's always good.

She sounds about the same vocally to me. I think that was a good song for her though.

Really. Why dont you go to the auditions next year?

Eh? I think she is fantastic :conf:

Just saying that she sounds the same there as she does now, but obviously that song suited her voice :laugh:

Oh, and I would never audition. One I am nowhere near as good as the majority who are on the show, and i know that. And two I would likely freeze with an audience that size :laugh2:

I loved anyone that performed creep. Both Treyc and Keri's performances were great.

i would not like to be her friend

Sorry. Misread it. My bad.:joker:

Cheryl is an awful mentor
she gives awful songs to ones who she doesnt care about.

look, face the fact that she will not win or get much further.

:sleep:

You've changed your tune from a few months back. Anyway, I thought you were leaving?

She certainly looks stunning this year.

well she should of put Gamu through shouldn't she..(over Katie)
I never said i was leaving

Treyc was good last year and is more polished this year, vocally more confident, sadly she is being mentored badly,the song choices are all over the place,but she does them all really well.

I hope she is in for a fair while yet.

No she shouldn't. Katie is quirky and interesting. Gamu was an overrated bore.

And yes you did - you made a big song and dance about it in a thread you made the other day. Stop trolling :sleep:

Cheryl is slowly bringing her down to her own poor level of singing

TreyC just needs the right song. She's been given repetitive songs(Relight, Whole lotta love) that dont really give her a chance to show anything other than its power.

A strong ballad is what she should sing.

She seemed to have more dynamic range last year. This year she strives to be loud all the time. It's a shame as she could probably go really far if she exercised a bit of restraint. For all intents and purposes, she is the most gifted vocalist in the competition.

over rated bore?
is that what the public thought of her was it?
oh wait thats what you thought of her..
She was so popular, she was favourite to win when she was OUT OF THE COMPETITION. Yeah..
And thousands of people joined campaigns to get her back..
Yeah she was really that boring.. Seriously though, she was not boring, and she was VERY TALENTED.

Katie was in the bottom 3 in week 1 Lmao

I know it's what I thought of her - hence why I posted it. When did I say everyone else thought the same?

Talk about stating the ****ing obvious, kid :joker:

Na I like her better this year, never really been a fan of her though.