Take That as a 4 or 5?
 

Do you prefer Take That as a four piece or a five piece? Or if you don't like do you think they're better as a 4 or 5? Just out of wonderment.

5, I remember them as a 5 piece and IMO they're better that way.

I like them better as a five piece, Robbie's my favourite member of the group. :love:

4, although they were overrated then, they're even more overrated now as a 5

Couldn't give a ****

Four,obviously.

Four piece.

Robbie is better going solo.

Much better as a four piece IMO!

4!

Five.

Hard to say, I really loved the old 5 member stuff from Take that, and also the songs they did with only 4 of them...
But to be honest, the latest new is disappointing

So, I liked 5, I liked 4, but don't like them to be 5 again

Don't mind really, I prefer Robbie's solo music to their work as a 5 piece though. (from what I've heard anyway).

I just want them to split up tbh so Mark releases another solo album.

I can never see Mark realeasing another solo album,much as I love his two later albums.

It has said for ages on his wiki that he'd already written/recorded some songs for his next album but it's gone now :nono:

Robbie and Garry.

****** the rest.

Wiki also once said that Mark had a 18 year old daughter and that he was a squirrel farmer. Not the most reliable source going :tongue:

Mark is the best. He was on Big Brother aswell thought you would love him just for that :nono:

Listen to this great song

4

I was never a fan of them in the 90s, but having heard their recent material they have really grown on me.

I get the excitement and nostalgia feeling as a 5 piece, but I don't think it would woke long term.

4.

They had a great thing when they came back as a 4 and now it's all about Robbie :bored:

Not a fan but I prefer the original line up. 5 is Take That. 4 aint

4. Robbie is a twat.

4, Their new album is awful and Robbie's drug fuelled staring is off putting.

Four definately, I even lost intrest in Robbie since he rejoined

Four. Only because I hate Robbie.

They seem to be enjoying themselves more with Robbie back. Plus Robbie seems more confident on stage...I think he has big psychological issues about performing.

So five.