Alisha Is Out - Good Or Bad Descion??
 

SIMON - Sending Home Alisha.
DANNII - Sending Home Alisha.
SHARON - Sending Home Hope
LOUIS - Sending Home Alisha!

So that means..

ALISHA!
Is Out!

Good Or Bad Descion??

Yes it was a good decision

I personally think that same difference should have gone

She wasn't the worst tonight...but to be fair, she was never going to win, and most of the acts are much better than her.

I think out of the last 2, it was a good choice but imo i'd rather Leon have gone home.

Alishas voice is not powerfull enough i think.Good reason.

Bad decision, she did brilliantly in her second performance. Same Difference should have gone, they're awful and way too cheesy.

Bad :C

SD have to go next week this is going OTT big time now serously if they are the winners they will have 1 number 1 then fade away....

IT WAS A BLOODY TRAVESTY IS WHAT IT WAS

NO!

Alisha outsung Hope in the bottom 2. Hope have to rely on Phoebe. If she wasn't there then they would have been out in the first week. Dannii knew well that the public wanted to see Alisha back, as the audience were chanting Alisha's name, and when Dermot asked one of the judges (I forget who) someone shouted out Hope very clearly.

Wrong result tonight, and if Louis was finding the decision hard then he should have sent home Hope and gone to the public vote.

DEFINITLEY NOT. The cheesy SD or Leon should have gone....

Bad I think she could have carried on too and I agree SD or Leon should have gone :conf2:

Good decision. Either her or Leon shud have gone... so glad one did.
Leon or Rhydian to go next week! :wink:

Very bad i wanted her to win o well she could have cam 12th but came 7th thats quite good.

Right decision out of the two in the bottom two, yes, but neither of them should have been there. Ridiculous..

It was a really bad decision.

Based on their performances in the bottom two, Alisha was miles better than Hope because she actually sang the song herself.

You couldn't hear Hope when they were on because the backing track was doing all the singing... Alisha was robbed tonight.

Bad decision, she's got so much potential and could be great and is great but just needed a better song and more confidence.

Out of the two that were in the bottom, it was the right decision. Alisha was weak tonight so probably deserved to be in the bottom2 but Hope shouldn't have been, and Alisha certainly wasn't the worst act tonight. And she really improved in her second performance and I actually thought she matched Hope's earlier performance.

Out of the bottom two it was the right decision but out of all the contestants Niki should have gone.

Out of the bottom 2 it was the right decision but overall she wasn't the worst.

It was bad. Alisha wasn't too good last night, but she has always been one of the best. Hope are rubbish!

It was Good alisha should have gone out 1st week!

Bad!!

good but bad out of the 2 acts espically as if she was better on her 2nd performance than her first

Not the worst performance last night but overall I'm glad she has gone.