Josie Gibson - how do you rank her against the final 5 this year?
 

BB11 winner Josie - for reasons I will never understand - was extremely popular and accrued 76% of the final vote (even though her toughest opposition was evicted before the final imho*).

Anyway, how do you rate this finalists as potential winners against her?




* At least no weak newbies made the final this year (JJ2 and Andrew last year)

I actually prefer ALL of this years finalists to Josie.

Josie is one of the worst housemates ever, nevermind just the worst winner.

Even Tom offered more than her as a housemate

I dunno tbh, I didn't really have a particularly strong opinion on her, she was overrated and dull but not really unlikeable

Worst winner ever, and one of the worst housemates of all time.

Ha ha!

I can't decide who I find more loathsome Jay or Josie. It's a toughie but I'll plump for Jay. At least Josie pooed in the toilette.

Me too Vicky appart from Jay, can't stand the guy.

The BB Freezer that got shat in, deserved to win more than Josie did.

Josie played the 'I'm Big & Dizzy' card last year, always a good tactic that one. Trying to pull Dave on the 'Gay Religion' stuff was a dirty move.

Can't stand Josie and not a worth winner in my opinion - the final 5 this year easily out rank her.

Think Josie would have come 4th/5th if she was in this years final.

She wouldn't have been as popular as Alex. Which is why I find her support of Alex a bit weird as Alex will probably replace her as the 'Go to' non-threatening BB bubby blond.

She is better than them all but Aaron

I am shocked - i thought i was the only person in the planet who couldn't stand her!!

She was better than Louise, but that's not saying much.

this^

Anyone but Josie. I couldn't stand her and still can't along with anyone I've ever spoken to. How she won is beyond me.

here's a better match up, battle of the dark lords
aaron vs marcus bb10

:joker::joker:

She had no opposition in the final (like Sophie Read BB10) - no Ben, no Corin, even 'crab eyes' would have been better - all evicted a few nights before in the quadruple pre-final eviction. She was always going to beat the newbies Andrew and Jo-John, Mario peaked on day 5 with the mole task and creepy Dave annoyed many with his religious 'I'm drunk on the Lord' spiel.

But this year, I reckon she definitely would have been up for eviction and been evicted when Aden went.

Apart from Anthony and Brian Bellend, Josie is the worst BB winner ever, as fake as a three pound note, and a nasty piece of work under all that blubber.

Aaron > Alex > Josie > Tom > Jay > Louise

Which Brian (I think both were poor - Dowling had no opposition and Belo is just a professional numpty)

I reckon she would have clashed with Anton had she had entered this year. Sigh, would have loved to have seen that.

I'm in the "Josie was worst ever" camp - she doesn't deserve consideration in any list of BB HMs ..... :yuk:

Ugh! Josie

I tend not to rate her....ever!

She was terrible. She only won because of the poor final we had and people saw her as the best of a bad bunch (even though Dave was far more superior than her)

If she was in this final:

Aaron > Alex > Tom > Louise > Josie > Jay

If she was in this final it would be
I think it would be (Josie/Alexs vote is cancelled out as they have some similar traits)
Aaron>Josie>Alex>Jay>Tom>Louise

What I would want
Aaron>Josie>Alex>Tom>Louise>Jay

Lol - I think Jay should give £500 as a generous gift to the freezer as worthy cotestant as it to put up with a lot of sh!t (and I mean literally)

Josie was a revolting, annoying, fat, lazy slob.

But do you think anyone this year will have Josie's post-BB media success?

She had a mag deal with OK! mag, column in another showbiz mag, got £3K to open a night club in Bath, modelling for plus size line, OK! TV presenting slot, guest appearances etc.
She's easily been one of the most successful BB house-mates since Jade

Josie was my least favourite house-mate ever.

A disgusting, fat, useless, revolting mess.

I even rate Louise over her.

Josie offered more than Tom has for sure, probably Louise as well. I find Alex funnier but again she's had zero storylines and so Josie offered more.

Jay and Aaron are the only ones who are far superior in terms of housemate credibility than her.

God help us if we get a Jayloo reality show.

Ofcom will be worked off their feet!

She was the worst HM of all time. Jealous bitter manhating mess, worst winner ever.

True and yes she'd have been long gone.
I thought before she lost her weight that she was pretty "the only thing she had going for her" but since she's lost it 'ugh" it's as though the real her is showing through and it certainly aint pretty.

I cant even recall who was in the final with her as I gave up well before final night.... good thing about this year is even though Alex is favourite it is by no means a foregone conclusion with all 5 in with a shot...well maybe not Tom....:devil:

Aaron > Tom > Alex > Josie > Jay > Louise

Aaron
Jay
Tom
Alex
Josie
Louise

It is interesting and unusual for two people in the public eye to both have west country accents ie Josie (Bath) and Aaron (Weston - super - Mare).
I like them both and hope Aaron makes it a double on Friday.