What's your opinion on this story (NSFW pic inside)
 

Do you think the story is true or fake? If true do you think he deserved this or should they have stopped at 19? I'm not sure if it's true because of the "laughs" in the URL.

http://i.imgur.com/0fF5EY7.jpg?1

The wardens should handcuff him to a bed and all go for a coffee break, let them do what they want to the scum bag.

If it's true that is.

^well said

Nah sorry don't agree with rape being used as a punishment

I don't have any time for him nor do I understand how he could do what he did. Execute him if you must, but to allow prisoners free reign to do this in a prison makes a complete mockery of the Brazilian justice system. Or is rape and torture okay so long as we can pick the victim?

^ Yeah on a wider level saying this should be turned a blind eye to also just encourages the anarchy you get in South American prisons where they're basically controlled by gangs at liberty to swan around murdering and raping at will

You think the 20 inmates who raped this guy haven't carried out disgusting crimes themselves?

People who hurt children repulse me and he deserves to be punished for it but he does not deserve to be raped multiple times while in prison. I think the fact it's happening on this scale is sickening, if he is being treated like this I can only imagine what horrible things happen to people who are sent to prison for petty crimes.

This. I don't have anything more to add tbh.

What I'm taking from the article is that they left him alone until they found out what he was in there for, so i don't really see how it can be assumed that it's happening to other people.

They took him to the hospital, got him fixed up, what more can they do? They can't keep an eye on him 24/7, they can't keep him locked up 24/7 because that would be against his human rights. sure they could try to segregate him from the people who did it, but it strikes me as it would happen to him wherever he was put.

I'm not saying it's right, but he deserves everything he gets, he should really count himself lucky that he's still alive, a lot of pedophiles don't last that long in prison, especially murdering ones.

Liam I think it's pretty naive to assume he is the only prisoner that will be getting raped in that prison.

And I think that it's pretty naive to assume that he isn't the only one, just because one person gets raped in a prison, by people aiming to give him a taste of his own medicine, doesn't mean a load of other people are being raped to.

So, they believe the fitting punishment for rape is to rape him themselves? Yep, that logic indicates the minds of these people.

Pretty much agree with this, both acts make me feel sick.

He's in prison. They should be keeping an eye on all of them 24/7. If 20 people rape someone... he gets patched up... then they rape him again, I'd say something's going wrong with their prison system.

The highlighted sentence is a contradiction.

It's not really a contradiction, bad people deserve to have bad things happen to them, at least in my eyes anyway, i don't agree with what they're doing exactly, but karma works in mysterious ways.

I do agree that something should have been done after the first incident though, it shouldn't have happened the second time.

But surely by your logic he deserved it the second time also?

Maybe so, but it shouldn't have happened, the people responsible proved their point the first time around, so it didn't necessarily need to happen again.. does that mean i feel sorry for him? no it doesn't.

How about the people who raped him? You're okay with whatever it is they did to end up in prison because they're raping a paedophile? There's no justification for this - not ever. I'd be happier with a death sentence, but to allow him to be tortured by other criminals is insane and uncivilised.

I'm torn about this. The human side of me says nobody deserves torture to this scale no matter what crime but then I think about the pain the child through and sympathy goes out the window. If you google report says the child had a fissure. He died 2 days after being brought to hospital he must have been in so much pain.

Kind of agree with this.

I do tend to think the people that raped aren't saints either because they are in jail for a reason as well. But then no crime is worst than harming a child. It's universal hatred.

Did i say that? no i didn't, please don't try and put words into my mouth.

I agree with you, it is uncivilised and insane in our culture, but they're much looser about these kinds of things over there, you'd never find anything like this happening over here, not a second time anyway, so maybe there is something wrong with their prison systems that needs to be worked on, but i feel no sympathy towards him whatsoever and you and other people can call me whatever you want, but he deserves what they handed to him the first time for what he did and i'll stand by that.

Education. Law. Justice. Education. Rules. Punishment. Education.

That said he should have been executed

He's a nonce so probably enjoyed it. This vigilante punishment is nowhere close to the price his son paid for no fault of his own, don't condemn nor agree with this tbh, couldn't care less.

It's not an assumption to say rape is rife in prisons. Also do you seriously believe 20 men in prison all decide to rape an inmate for the first time ever after hearing about his crimes and that before that they had never done anything like it before?

I don't care for his welfare, but nor will I say 'Good on the other prisoners!' because they're scums of the earth as well as him.

Why is that so hard to believe? They could have been men with young kids who wanted to teach the scumbag a lesson, you can't just assume that everyone is going around raping anything that moves in there, we don't know anything that's happening there, so unless any of us see what it's like there, we'll never know who's right.

The normal human reaction to finding out about a rapist isn't "Let's go rape him!"

I personally wouldn't do that type of vigilantism at any scenario imo, but I'm not exactly upset for the guy as he committed the two worst crimes by law and by my opinion.

Scumbag 1: aw man you hear we got a child rapist a couple of cells down from us.

Scumbag 2: aw sick dude. That's totally disgusting man. I only snuck into an old couples house at nighttime, slit their throats and took all their valuables and you only hijacked that bus full of imams and drove it off the river bank but nah this is too much for me man what has society come to?

Scumbag 1: I know Knuckles. When we were young it was just mobbing old grannies and popping Feds with a colt .22 when they come near our drug stash. This fella done much worse, then he killed the poor kid after.

Scumbag 2: that's not right man. Where was the discipline for this plonker?

Scumbag 1: well what we gunna do? We can't let filthy child rapists get away with sh*t on our ward.

Scumbag2: I know! Let's rape him.

Scumbag 1: good idea man. Was tired of shagging you anyway.

I said it in another topic and I'll say it again, punishing a sex crime with a sex crime is senseless and I honestly worry for the people that think rape as a punishment is justified. If this is true then I hope all prisoners involved were charged with rape, they are no better than the sick bastard they raped.

How is this in the Chat & Games section lol? Has the OP got plans for all of us lol?

Child Rape and general rape puts you at the very bottom of the Prison hierarchy. Don't dont do crime and you wouldn't have to deal with that.

not a good idea to let this go unpunished otherwise it makes a mockery of the Brazilian justice system

This pretty much.

Tough call. In general, I think these prisons clearly need to be better policed because, it's true if this was able to happen twice then it strongly indicates that terrible things are happening to people who are in for less horrific crimes. So in general, I am very much against vigilante justice in prisons. As has also been mentioned - the men doling out this sort of thing are clearly also violent criminals (before this), so how c a n you applaud it?

On the other hand, I have absolutely no sympathy for this monster, and I agree that nothing they could possibly do to him compares to the damage he must have done to that child before he died. His own son, for Christ's sake. Taking the wider context of the clearly broken prison system there out of consideration: I hope he dies of septicaemia, and I'm glad that he's suffered in the run up to that. There is no other fitting outcome for his crime.