Who shouldn't have been cast this year?
 

So, we all know production has hit rock bottom this year. However, casting was the only thing marginally OK about this series. That being said, how many do you think actually deserved to be cast on the merit of their personality and presence alone?

I think the people who deserved to be cast are: Adjoa, twins, Chloe, Harriet, Jack, Jade, Joel, Kieran, Nick, Sam and Sarah - quite a lot. Yes, Adjoa and Jade are models but at least Adjoa had a personality, and Jade was a fan of the show.

The people in my opinion who shouldn't have been cast are: Aaron, Cristian, Danny, Eileen, Harry Amelia, Marc and Simon. All either fame-hungry or useless recruits who add nothing to the house whatsoever. Who would you say? Remember this is not who you like/dislike but who deserved to be cast in BB16.

Poll coming. :)

I generally don't care about whether someone is a recruit or not, that doesn't bother me, what bothers me more are people who go in there and add nothing to the show for me personally, so for me Aaron, Cristian, Chloe, Danny and Jack.

To add to my post, the reason I picked Eileen and Simon is because it angers me that the only older people represented in the house had to be two people already involved in the media. Like Harriet said, that's not an accurate representation of our society and is so damn boring to watch!

Don't you think Chloe represents the average BB viewer more than any other housemate in there (with the exception of Nick)? For me, that alone makes her deserving of being there. Like she said, she's watched the show for years, will always be a normal person and just wanted to do something special before she settled down. The fact that such a normal person got through the casting process filled with models etc makes her even more deserving in my opinion, as that couldn't have been easy!

Marc is the only glaring example for me. He's not as OTT horrible now as he was after his fake eviction but his boring, fabricated personality and bullying has still made me turn off the tv many times. He's the biggest series destroyer I've seen on BBUK. There's not much use for people like Simon or Sam either but at least they mostly keep their mouths shut.

Nah not really, 'normal' to me doesn't directly correlate to 'deserving' there have been many, many normal people over the years and not all of them have been deserving, to me a 'deserving' housemate is someone who makes the most of the, primarily, once in a life time opportunity, I'd rather be entertained by a recruit than bored to tears by a 'normal person' :laugh:

And if we look at it technically, people in media these days, are becoming the norm, our society as a whole is so reliant on the media and social media presence these days that it's not all that unusual to be scene as 'somebody' especially with the powers of Twitter and Youtube.

A 'normal' person could go in there and be the biggest dick in the entire world, whereas a recruit could go in there and be the nicest, funniest person in the world and that's what matters to me, not what their job is or how they got onto the show, don't get me wrong, it is nice to see people like Harriet go on there and be from a humble background, but someone being scouted isn't detrimental to my viewing experience or my opinion of them.

Fair, I respect your opinion. However I think once you go through auditions and see so many 'normal' people with fascinating personalities and then the cast ends up having recruits like Danny and Cristian instead, it can be infuriating. Also, whilst I see your point, the average UK citizen/BB viewer hasn't been on a reality tv show with Winston (BB15) or is best friends with Ricci from Geordie Shore like Danny. The average UK citizen/BB viewer also wouldn't have a Vevo channel on youtube.

Recruiting is a very beneficial process to Big Brother UK as you can get characters like Derek BB6 who was totally deserving of his place. However, the way Channel 5 recruits nowadays, it's never on the basis of personality imo, even though it should be. Agreed about Harriet though, the best moment of the series for me was when she said how much being on the show meant to her, in her eviction interview.

Remember, people like Danny and Cristian don't even have to go through the whole audition process like someone like Chloe would've done, as they get fast-tracked to the final stages as they 'have a celebrity friend'. This also contributes to me thinking they're less deserving of their place in the house.

Cristian and Kieran both have added nothing to the series and have been tediously boring to watch. It was good Kieran went early on otherwise you could guarantee he would still be in that house now without the 4In4Out twist. He was just wallpaper as is Cristian now.

The others as much as I dislike or like them have proven in some way that they should have been cast and have added something to the series

very unfair on danny at present - hope it changes as more vote - please remember what has nick done apart from flick hair ? or sam ?

I don't really mind if people aren't "normal", and I wouldn't say someone didn't deserve to be cast beaus they're not but I do prefer the normal. I Think Marc is too fake nasty, like obvious game-playing. Helen last year was just a nasty person, and I kinda prefer that. Cristian has given very little and shown little respect when saying "WHO the ******* was that" when Pete came in.
I just think if you have a unique or entertaining personality naturally you deserve to be on this show, if not, bore off.

Eileen was a goddess and a "recruit" it's such a boring argument. The only eh signing really was Keiran. He was never going to fit in. But I enjoyed him.

And technically Jack is a recruit as well. He was on tv daily for a month at least.

Aaron,Cristian,Danny,Simon and marc

There's nothing inherently wrong with recruits, Lucas. Hira was a recruit and she's my favorite female housemate of all time. The issues is when recruits get recruited just for the looks or because of acquaintances they have. The further issue is when they get preferential treatment in casting and get fast-tracked.

Especially Cristian and Danny

:clap1: I told you from Day 1 buddy that they were useless!!

Voted for every single one of them.

Thanks for explaining further luv. It looked like you had issues with recruits in general just for producers daring to cast them!

I find it awful how Sarah and Harriet went over Danny :bored:

but Cristian will never have been casted if he wasn't attractive and I liked Danny at first but he turned into a bore and a dick.

Nick, Harry and Marc.
Nick and Harry might as well stay in the bed for the whole duration, he needs help for the face touching and nose picking.

Marc is too OTT, saying nasty things, doing nasty things, doesnt take no for an answer, goads people. There is a point where it becomes too much and Marc goes past that point a lot. I also think he has stopped other HM's developing.

Still pressed about Sarah and Harriet leaving prematurely.


In all honesty I think Adjoa was a massive mistake, she was awfully overrated and fell way too short of any hopes I had of her. The twins were also useless.

Sam and Harry Amelia are pretty poor casting choices too. They're not entertaining and I knew from the start that their VT personas were not going to be fulfilled yawn

I voted Jade by accident :fist:

Danny, Cristian, Aaron and Jack for being generally bad housemates. Twins as I hate a duo housemate... And Joel because if he is serious about his political dreams he's come to the wrong place.

Most of them. The only ones that deserved to go in because they actually DID something are Adjoa, Eileen, Harriet, Jade, Joel, Kieran and Nick

Aaron absolutely should have been cast. We were robbed of another Craig and Anthony storyline, there's no way he was a bad housemate.

Chloe and Sam shouldn't have been cast tbh. Both dullards.

Craig/Anthony wasn't good the first time round though

Haha nah it's not that at all! There have been so many recruits (Imogen, Hira, Rachelle BBCAN, Kenny BBCAN) etc whom I think were outstanding housemates. It's just the Channel 5 bull**** with recruits :laugh:

So glad to see Danny topping this :clap1:

Aaron was one of the most entertaining housemates this year ...

One of the best storylines of all time I think you'll find

Adjoa was a terrible signing.

All she could say was pusszee and when she got fed up of that she turned into a wallflower.

Mega boring.

Aaron, Cristian, Danny, Marc, and Simon.

Marc and Sam are the worst two castings for me. Marc as he got casted to play the "Character, villain, riler..." etc. And Sam as she was a total dud. The 4in4out was done to bring in better personalities than the ones going out (?) and it was a complete injustice for Sarah to get swapped out with bloody Sam of all people - total non-entity.

Casting was awful this year, the original housemates were garbage and any with potential were evicted....this year has been the worst ever, the old faces coming back has been the best part.

I think they all deserved to be cast. Nothing is inherently wrong with any of them as individual housemates. The issue for me is that the mix of housemates turned into something bland.

I do take issue with someone saying Marc, Cristian etc are not deserving because of their careers yet supporting Jade. Jade was a fantastic housemate and the one eviction I really disagreed with but she also works in media and even auditioned for the same reality show Marc was on in Dublin. To clarify I think Jade & Marc were both deserving housemates, I'm just disagreeing with a false distinction between their eligibility for the house.

Tried watching this years big brother as I have been away for a few weeks but I seemed to be caught in a time loop all I can see is Nikki graham and Helen and aislyne and Brian B..

What is going on .... Are all current hm just boring now so they are using controversial ex hm from past series.

The words barrel, bottom and scraping come to mind....!!!

Aaron was one step away from being a rapist so him and also Chloe she brings nothing to the house doesn't even have nice legs or tits on her get her out.

Marc, Simon & Jack - all three are immature self absorbed individuals with very little to offer except nasty comments and bad vibes in the house.

Aaron, goes without saying!

Without the live feed i really can't say if people are dull or not, everyone was overshadowed with the prats from the past going in, it may have turned into a half decent year without them.

Plus Marc, i know some find him entertaining but he just turns my stomach.