Worst channel 5 winner? Helen or Aaron
 

Discuss x

Helen, bullying makes me feel sick

Definitely Helen. Lord Aaron >

Helen but both are awful and don't have a patch on Chloe :clap1:

Helen, no idea how she's comparable to Aaron but yeah

If you asked me a year ago I would've said Aaron but Helen's win has aged sooooooooo badly that I am really not sure

Well Helen is an awful winner, housemate and person so her

(I also think that Sam's worse than Aaron but that's only because I haven't watched BB12 in full) (or, like, at all) (and I'm not willing to change that any time soon)

Helen has no redeeming qualities about her

Um, Helen remains the worst Big Brother UK winner of all time.

I might just stick with Aaron as the worse winner just to have some variety in this thread. I know we all like to block BB12 out of our memories but he really was that bad.

:clap1:

I can't believe this is even a question

I haven't seen BB12. Why do ppl hate Aaron?

I'd vote Helen for this one, Aaron was my favourite from the first week in that series, I would never consider him a bad or unworthy winner by any standards.

Helen by a mile.

Both are equally trash this is hard :worry:

Aaron is C5's best civilian winner (admittedly mainly by default), and Helen is the worst by a million miles.

Helen

Aaron was the best c5 winner, and possibly near the best overall winner too...

He was a petulant, whiny brat. He would throw tantrums and fits all the time when things didn't go his way (BUT I DON'T WANT TO LISTEN TO R&B! BUT I DON'T WANT INDIAN FOOD!) and was a huge hypocrite. He would hold grudges for days on end and place people on speaking bans because everything was about how offended he was and his sense of propriety, but how dare anyone be mad at him! He would try to justify every petty, attention-seeking move he did like throwing the shopping task and sabotaging the shopping budget (because he hated like two other HMs and took it upon himself to punish everyone around him) but would it would be so against his morals for people to burp near him.

Also, his relationship with Faye was really emotionally abusive and uncomfortable. He'd do something really shady (kiss another girl, place her on a speaking ban because she burped in his proximity, call her a two-faced gameplayer for not cutting ties with Louise or whatever) and put on a wounded production about how upset HE was, get Faye to apologize to him and try to patch things up, and then he'd smother her with "I love you"s at night in bed and act like they were just friends the next morning. Think Steven and Kimberly before they happened.

Macie :love:

Helen! I loved Aaron. Over the moon when he won! Helen and Aaron, no comparison at all!

Great vote! However moderators seems not to be to happy about it....

Aaron was the best winner EVER.

Aaron was my King :worship:

Both are the best and most deserving winners of all time

Aaron is a better person though (not often I judge on that) so him

Who voted for Aaron :suspect:

oh dear

Macie's Aaron analysis :clap1:

He may be worse.

but why was Helen deserving? her treatment towards Jale,Christopher and Chris was really uncomfortable to watch and it wasn't good tv at all. Awarding that (won;t shock me if steven voted for her loads of times) is not a good message at all. Aaron was good tv, Helen wasn't imo

The rated called Helen.

:douf:

Thought I'd landed on another planet with this thread. Comparing him to Helen :huh:

I don't think that this thread's implying that they're similar in personalities, because they're not. They just both happen to have **** personalities ^_^

Helen 100%

Aaronn was the best winner ever...the underdog no one ever thought would win against all the odds stacked against him.

Helen.

From the poll I chose Helen. But Sam is Channel 5's worst winner.