Was Siavash wrong to blame Tom?
 

He certainly felt a tad guilty, but they shook hands.

snitch, grass

He admitted he could have made a mistake, to me it did look like he thought Tom did it.

siavash is a shitstirring nob.

Yes. I'm starting to dislike him now a bit

Sez Tom :thumbs:

Afterwards it looked to me like Siavash was trying cement a good relationship incase it went pete tong on him.

i neve got the whole stolen beer gate thing :puzzled::rolleyes: i neva saw anything so i havent got a clue who stole lisa's beer maybe nobody did and maybe lisa secretly drank it pretending sum1 stole it to cause trouble!!!! who knows!

i'm not sure if it's worth commenting on cuz as always, we're left without any visual evidence so it would be silly to make a judgement on the whole thing.

Where was sirvash's proof?

he says he could be wrong??

In my book, you wanna be 100% sure before you shout thief

and over Lisas beer??? :shrug: who gives a shite about Lisas beer?

:dance:
yes i think siavash was wrong to blame him in front of everyone,i like siavash but i really felt for tom,especially that he is a newbie and must have felt so embarrassed but i think he handled it well and there is no bad feelings between them now

If he wasnt a 100% then he should have ****, Siavash is starting to get on my nerves.

you always did

in short,yes..i see he just wanted to be straight up about what he thought was up but he went about it as if it was straight fact then when challenged on it he seemed a little less certain.dont dislike siavash abit just think it was a little strange to single him out like so..toms good spirit afterwards was a good change to the usual awkward atmosphere which is common place in there..

He was well out of order. He had no proof and although i dislike Tom Siavash was incredibly stupid to name him as the thief.

I actually thought that was quite odd to be honest, it was like he was kissing Lisa'a backside and couldnt wait to tell tales to her, very odd.

Siewash is the most sophisticated game player on the show. What he did was very risky but he has managed to sow the seeds of doubt in everyones' minds about Tom being untrustworthy. then he makes a humble apology making himself look good to everyone except Tom.

Siewash does not know that Tom can not be voted for this week so he has put his own head on the block a week early.

Siewash is also pretty certain he will not be voted out. It has not gone unnoticed by the other housemates that the 'bunnygate' twosome, Kris and karly were voted out. Housemates think that there was truth in that.

What pissed me off was that he said that Tom took it without any doubt at first then started backtracking. If he wasn't 100% sure in the first place he should have kept his mouth shut.

What happend to his moral high ground.

Siavash is brilliant, i thought it was bloody hilarious xD

Well at the time Siavash seemed to think he did; but he should have emphasized the fact that Tom may have done it by accident.

I don't like how Siavash tries to make a scene and have himself be the 'announcer'.

Turned out that Tom didn't do anything wrong and Lisa was happy with what he proved to her. It got cleared up and they're all good friends.

Tom is a laid back kinda guy, he's not into this BS. He's too alpha for that.

I don't think Siavash would have accused him unless he genuinely thought that he had taken it. Whether tom did take it or not? We will never know, but someone must have! Unless Lisa was lying?

i like him, but he was defenatly wrong to say what he said

i mean, you just dont say anything that you dont kno especially when the person your accusing is in front of a group of people

this actually made me think that siavash is playing it a little bit....

I didn't really understand Tom's "proof". How did showing Lisa where his tin and his cupcake was, prove that he did not drink an extra one? I think he maybe did drink it, but without thinking he was doing any wrong?

It's one of those things where it would have been really nice to actually see what happened, but Big Brother decided not to bother using the power of HAVING CAMERAS WATCHING EVERYONE EVERYWHERE.

How do we know Tom DIDN'T drink it?

How do we know he did? in either case its hearsay with Siavash back tracking.

we dont kno that he did or didnt, but i still think siavash was wrong on what he did cuz saying in fron of hes face whles everyone will hear it is kinda something i didnt expect for him to do.
but either way the guy looked shock when siavash accused him.

Siavash looked really drunk, but I think he had more proof than was shown. BB are just trying to engineer halfwit to win so they're trying to knock the next popular housemate.
I'd say tom prob did take it, maybe by accident. Siavash wasn't wrong to bring it up. If he didn't they'd have been bitching about it all night.
Tom is a hoover for food and drink, he prob lost count and drank the lot quickly.

I don't think Siavash would just accuse someone without genuinely thinking it to be true.. I think Tom maybe did drink it without thinking he was doing any wrong.
I think Siavash agreed to call a truce just to get on with the party and not ruin the night.
Someone must have taken the drink.. so if it wasn't Tom, who was it?

well said matey, well said :thumbs:

Backtracking. Exactly the same thing he did during rabbit-gate. First made a statement like it was a definite fact then changed his mind after

I like Siavash but he really shouldn't have accused Tom like that without solid proof.

These threads are pointless, because you just get siavash fans giving completely biased defense...quite sad really.

Btw, yes he was, and he made a complete cock out of himself...hence rodrigo almost crying with laughter at how pathetic it was.

Who cares who took the extra beer. As we have seen before people who are accused never take it.

Prob Lisa cause trouble as usual

yeah thats wot i was thinking! but cause tom protested sooooooooo much :rolleyes: people think he's innocent! ,i think he either sneakily took it or took it not relising it was lisa's :sleep:

:spin::thumbs:

2nd time sivash blames more things

Lisa should have let it lie, there are lots in the house, most likely a mistake, she put a downer on the whole night the evil old hag

but why make a massive scene
just deal with it with people concerned only

You can't call people thieves unless you were 100% certain.

So yes, Siavash was in the wrong.

He really was. Siavash is such a plank, he thinks he knows it all. First he was like "I know who took it", then, when he said who, he was like "I'm not accusing you" WTF? He's such a penis.