Lucie or Stacey?
 

Both Are the only 2 girls in My Top 5 now...

So I have to ask to see whos more liked..


Who do you lot like more...

Stacey Soloman
or
Lucie Jones (I think thats her last name)

Lucie Jones by far.

Lucie Jones and Stacy Soloman are my top 2.

But Lucie edges it, i also think Stacy Mclean is great and slightly underated.

I think Girls could win it again.

I agree, I forget her name xD Lucie is best

Lucie Jones

I dont like that chavvy girl

Stacey, actually both of them

which one is Lucie?

I prefer Stacey. Think Lucie is technically flawless but Stacey has a warmth and fragility to her once she starts performing. And I prefer her tone too.

Neither really. At a push Lucie, she's incredibly dreary but can sing a tiny bit better than Stacey.

[rquote=2609840&tid=148210&author=Tom]Stacey, actually both of them

which one is Lucie? [/rquote]

<object width="560" height="340"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/KCAJdq1UpK4&hl=en&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/KCAJdq1UpK4&hl=en&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="560" height="340"></embed></object>



Both are amazing singers i believe.

Stacey, Lucie's got a nice voice but there's nothing else to her.

john and edward 2 win. xxxxxxx
love the guyz xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

oh her, shes good but shes boring, plus a low rate Leona

They are both exactly the same. They both are unbelievably skinny. Same hair type. Similar vocals, not too strong, but in tune. Soft songs, will never be able to handle up tempo.
they are pointless the both of them, and apparently Danni picks them both for the live. I dont know what she was thinking. At least she couldve just picked one.

Honestly though, I really love Rachel's tone. You can't buy a voice like that or train somebody to sing in that fashion. She'll never win but she's my fav outta the three of them.

[rquote=2609856&tid=148210&author=staceyxxx]john and edward 2 win. xxxxxxx
love the guyz xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx[/rquote]


now why doesnt this surprise me.

[rquote=2609861&tid=148210&author=Aint_mad_atcha]They are both exactly the same. They both are unbelievably skinny. Same hair type. Similar vocals, not too strong, but in tune. Soft songs, will never be able to handle up tempo.
they are pointless the both of them, and apparently Danni picks them both for the live. I dont know what she was thinking. At least she couldve just picked one.[/rquote]

yeah it would kind of be nice if you kept the spoilers in the spoiler thread, thats the whole point of it. thanks for probably spoiling the girls bit of next weeks show

Don't get how people can judge personality on what they have seen so far.
Both can sing very well.

[rquote=2609869&tid=148210&author=Tom][rquote=2609861&tid=148210&author=Aint_mad_atcha]They are both exactly the same. They both are unbelievably skinny. Same hair type. Similar vocals, not too strong, but in tune. Soft songs, will never be able to handle up tempo.
they are pointless the both of them, and apparently Danni picks them both for the live. I dont know what she was thinking. At least she couldve just picked one.[/rquote]

yeah it would kind of be nice if you kept the spoilers in the spoiler thread, thats the whole point of it. thanks for probably spoiling the girls bit of next weeks show [/rquote]

Aye.

its pretty obvious both of these are going to go through though isnt it? most airtime, most popular.

[rquote=2609869&tid=148210&author=Tom][rquote=2609861&tid=148210&author=Aint_mad_atcha]They are both exactly the same. They both are unbelievably skinny. Same hair type. Similar vocals, not too strong, but in tune. Soft songs, will never be able to handle up tempo.
they are pointless the both of them, and apparently Danni picks them both for the live. I dont know what she was thinking. At least she couldve just picked one.[/rquote]

yeah it would kind of be nice if you kept the spoilers in the spoiler thread, thats the whole point of it. thanks for probably spoiling the girls bit of next weeks show [/rquote]

Youre welcome! NOw go cry to someone who cares!

Lucie Jones<3

My top 3 faves out of the girls in this order:

lucie
stacey soloman
rachel

I do hope these 3 go through!

I love both Stacey's but Lucie is just unbelievable. Been my fav since her first audition

I love both but I like Lucie just a bit more. i dont know why as well but i want both of them to get through

[rquote=2609904&tid=148210&author=Aint_mad_atcha][rquote=2609869&tid=148210&author=Tom][rquote=2609861&tid=148210&author=Aint_mad_atcha]They are both exactly the same. They both are unbelievably skinny. Same hair type. Similar vocals, not too strong, but in tune. Soft songs, will never be able to handle up tempo.
they are pointless the both of them, and apparently Danni picks them both for the live. I dont know what she was thinking. At least she couldve just picked one.[/rquote]

yeah it would kind of be nice if you kept the spoilers in the spoiler thread, thats the whole point of it. thanks for probably spoiling the girls bit of next weeks show [/rquote]

Youre welcome! NOw go cry to someone who cares![/rquote]

ah well, i'm not too fussed about the girls but it would be nice to wait until the show ... sure a few others think the same. but if they were black i bet you'd like them both