Brenda v Stacey
 

Another comparison poll based on a song done before on the show

Brenda series 2 (clip to jog memory if you want to see it)



Stacey series 6 (clip only because its fair :tongue:)



I forgot how good Brenda actually was, probably best singer they've ever had on the show, but LOL @ how cheesy the show was back then

I like them both, but Stacey did it better for me.

stacey

For me, Brenda.
Even through all them dodgy, old-school dance moves lol!
Lovely soulful voice.
:)

Clearly Brenda is 10000000x better. That was week one aswell and she moved around that whole stage.

Brenda - my favorite XF contestant ever. Love her.

Brenda the defenda!

I loved both, they were my favourites in both years. I've voted for Stacey though to give her a vote :laugh:

Brenda's was better though.

Brenda, Stacey's was a ****ing mess.

Brenda,love Stacey more but Brenda's version of that is better

As much as i love Stacey i think Brenda's was better.

Brenda

Oh bless Brenda.. she dances as if she's at a school disco embarrassing her son in front of all his friends. Love it.

I'll pick Stacey cos I hate these old comparisons.. not going to effect actual voting this weekend. "oh I wont vote Stacey... because Brenda sang it better"

Brenda was better.. but Stacey was still very good

Brenda :)

stacey,,
i dislikeeed brenda! :/

brenda