Jones V Reid-Who would win?
 

I reckon if "The Reidenator" wanted to he would rip Vinnie apart.Vinnie plays tough guys in films-Alex does it for a living.

Vinnie :(

Vinnies just a bitch hes no hard man.

We've already had this discussion, Vinnie would win because he is the more aggressive one (only if he got in first though, because Alex is agile).

Fights are messy, in a real fights rules and blocking go out the window. Vinnie is bigger and more aggressive and would win but in the ring with rules than Alex

Vinnies pretty tough and a bit of a nutter-Alex has let him away with murder and sholda called him out.

Cisco V Jonas-now that would be a blood-bath.

alex

I think Alex would win, but doesn't stop him being a pointless moron

I think Vinnie would win, but on the other hand it could be Alex!

Didn't Vinnie get beaten up in a bar in the states this year?

I think it's pretty obvious that Alex would win this. He trains to fight hours a day and could probably KO Vincent in one punch! Vinnie has got to where he is today by acting tough and being a Crazy Gang member which I like him for, but let's be realistic, Alex would leather him everywhere!

Are we really having this discussion again?

How exactly is Vinnie more aggressive?

Alex Reid has had over fifteen MMA fights against other similarly, highly trained fighters who were trying to knock his head off, he has also had many full contact thai boxing fights.

Vinnie played football for Wimbledon, played a tough guy in a Guy Ritchie film then got beat up in a bar in America by a no mark.

There is no evidence to suggest Vinnie Jones is more aggressive AT ALL, yet there is PLENTY of evidence to suggest that Alex Reid is highly aggressive.

I don't get it, are you people lacking common sense?!

It's like saying "oh sure, Roger Federer would beat me at tennis if we played on centre court at Wimbledon with actual rules and referees, but if we played in the park on a concrete court I'd win because I'm more aggressive and it's my turf".

It's total b*llocks.

Alex would win because he is a professional fighter!

Alex is annoying because all he goes on about is how he hates the papers going on about him. So what do you do when you're fed up of that? You go on Big Brother!

alex would obviously win.

Been there done this three times now. At the moment they are so pally they are more likely to boff eachother than fight!

Vinnie would kill him

Alex would be to scared to move

Alex has already lost the first part of the fight, in the mind. He allows Vinnie to walk all over him and still shows respect to him.

I can't believe people are judging the outcome of a fight between these two based on their behavior in the Big Brother house.

Because Alex is fairly laid back and not one of the prominent "leaders" in the house, does not mean that if it came to a situation where a fight broke out, he would not batter Vinnie Jones.

You can tell by the way Vinnie Jones holds the pads for Alex when he "trains" him in the garden that he does not have a clue about fighting.

This is a social experiment, not a physical violence experiment.

Vinnie is much older than Alex, far more wise to the world and obviously much more adept within social situations and has a lot more confidence and self assurance.

In a FIGHT however, where NONE of these social rules apply, the person who has trained intensely for many years and participated in full contact fighting with other equally trained fighters, is clearly and quite obviously going to win.

Some of the best mixed martial arts fighters in the world are extremely reserved and quiet in real life and would no doubt bore the nation rigid if they took part in Big Brother.

But does that mean if a regular person with more self confidence fought them that they would win?

Of course not, don't be ridiculous.

The people on here who think Vinnie would win a fight are throwing common sense out of the window.

You are basically saying that Vinnie would win due to his superior social skills.

:conf: