Appreciation sub forum in Music
 

Going from this thread. Digital Spy have one under Big Brother for appreciation threads, I think that could be useful in music where its hard to filter through threads to find something worthwhile

I don't see the point really. GaGa, Britney and Take That are the only ones that are regularly active [though Christina and Ellie Goulding's will probably more in use soon]. It keeps the Music forum more active and brings topics to people's attention if they say, just came on to check one of the appreciation threads.

Its only not an issue for those who don't post in them. Plus if comes up in the side bar if anyone does have an interest in the singer

I'm not fussed either way, I don't use the appreciation threads but they don't bother me.

I endorse this suggestion.

http://www.esquire.com/cm/esquire/im...ts-1108-lg.jpg

Enid approves.

LEts av it

Good Idea! (:

Hmmm, not sure.

On a side-note, I've been thinking X Factor artists threads should be moved to the X Factor forum.

What say you?

You make no sense.

Nah, as far as I'm concerned once they've left the show they're no longer part of the 'X Factor', and are artists just like everyone else.

HE MADE NO SENSE JACK.
I screamed.

Well they aren't artists for a start, Jack_ :p

But I'm not too fussed about that.

Let's just split the Music forum in two : Music and Real Music.

... oh yes. Nazi's in da haus, baby.

I don't see what Leona, Diana, JLS or Alexandra really have to do with the show now, most people are fans of them as artists rather than XF acts so I don't think so no.

Yeah, but for the purpose of this discussion let's just call them artists :tongue:

I'd say Leona is the only one that is deserving of a place in the Music forum. The others are all still strongly associated with the show.

It would be better for the http://www.thisisxfactor.com/ page if X Factor threads were back in the X Factor forum also. Keep it more active.

On the subject of the appreciation threads, not sure it is worth a separate forum as there only looks to be about three threads that are titled 'appreciation' or 'fan-club'.

:conf:
http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru...ad.php?t=92839

Theres loads

Only a few are active though. The sub forum would just become a library of lists. Which is already in that link you posted.

No, Diana Vickers should say in music. As should Alexandra and JLS.