Would Janey Cutler get through if she was 25 years old?
 

I rest my case.

(the answer is not a chance in hell).

Probably, she would have been in time an would have sounded better

I expect so.

i dont think so, she wouldnt be as funny if she wasnt old

Possibly, I would think so.

no way.

probably not.

aww i wanted the pirates to get through, they were better than diversity

I didnt think she was that good, not half as good as they was making her out to be imo.

Fusion/Twist & Pulse for me.

I doubt it

Anyone is better than SuBo;):D.

I think if she performs no regrets again at the final she could have a good shot at winning it

I think being that old is part of her act though. Connected wouldn't have got through had they been 18.

Is she the act for the Royal Variety though? To sing to the Queen? Cos all this hype and she will win

Like subo did?

Just pointing out a possibility....

She is perfect for the Royal variety and yes she could of performed better at 25..

She is a good singer, she is 80 ffs.

Would diversity won if they were not black?

would Sampson won if he had been 43?

would anyone have bothered about SuBo if she did not look a little downs?

Absolutely. But there's a resonance to her voice that was probably at it's best in her mid-life.

Besides the point.
For her age, she sounds as good as Leona Lewis.
You cannot compare her to a 25 year old.

I think she sounds absolutely rubbish. I've heard better 80 year olds. Completely gimmicky and untalented.

You've heard better 80 year olds? Are you having a laugh? The girl's great. Such a unique and natural voice.

Your question should be could a 25 year old sing like her and the answer would be no. You can't teach somebody to sing like that. Either have it or don't.

I can't take these comments seriously. She sounds horrendous.

This is just some kind of a joke.

No her being old is one of her selling points that makes her act original.

I don't think so, But then again would Susan Boyle have had so much fuss made over her if she was a 25 year old attractive woman? Don't think so. Twist and Pulse are my faves :)