I like the new Katie :D
 

I really do :D
x

I liked the old Katie, but the new Katie is better!

New Katie Old Katie both annoying as hell

Loved her tonight and last sunday.

Lose the silly costumes and pick the right songs for your voice range.

She's better, but I still hate her.

She hasn't had her hair down since her first audition, it's always bloody up! :rolleyes:

At her best she's a second-rate Daina Vickers without the pop star looks and twice as annoying.

Please vote her OFF!

this

Agreed. She'sjust playing the game. Wouldn't believe anything she says to be quite honest with you. She does have presence though.

Didn't like the performance tonight either, it was a bit better than last week but only just,the real improvement was the removal of the tupperware plates/bowls off her head.

She is still way down my list,only slightly better than Cher this week.Then again Cher was really awful.

I don't think she's changed. D:

Love her anyway though :D

Much, much better tonight...and I have been a fan all the way so far.

I cannot understand how anyone could slate her vocal tonight. Beautiful performance. Very intriguing.

:puzzled:I don't see any difference!

Love her voice. Like Cher, I don't warm to her

It's a game show.


Jesus.

Once you take away the strange accessories she uses, she just seems plain and average to me.. still I'm sure she sings a lot better than I do. Diana Vickers has done it before and done it better too.

if you take away the gimmicks and her trying to be different shes actually really good. If she was just herself from the start I very much doubt there would be all the bad press about her

Actually its a talent contest Paddy..