Name me one person who the judges would NOT save katie over?
 

The only people I can think of are Cher...and One direction.

I honestly think if anyone else was in the bottom with her, they would save her, regardless of the performances.

Well apparently she can even ***** up her performance and still stay!

i cant be 100% sure who they would send her home over now.

This is only the second time she's been saved, and tbf TreyC really isnt that great and FYD were shocking.

Yup...

I can actually imagine Rebecca and Katie in the bottom, and them sending rebecca home...or sending matt home even over her :/

I love this forum when everyone is pissed off :)

:laugh:

she got through boot camp by not signing and bursting into tears.

She's got through tonight with a ****ty performance, over played by her amateur dramatics - ala collapse - on stage.

What a waste of time this show has now become. A farce. Total Farce.:cloud:

Would go:
Matt
Rebecca
One Direction
Cher
Mary

Maybe:
Aiden
Paije

Would stay:
Wagner

Third time actually - she was in the bottom two with Belle Amie last week.

:laugh2:


(And woo for Katie :love:)

I will love you just as much when Katie finally gets her scrawny little neck booted off. her time will come, that you can be sure of. And I'll be the first to come knocking on your day with a big grin. :joker:

Love that Simon called her a drama queen on Xtra factor and was like "She knows what she's doing. Falling all voer the floor like that."

Just send them both home now why don't they. FIX.

yet he fell for it ;)

Yeah, but this was the second time she's been saved, last week went to deadlock.

Ah right I get you. I think last week it was obvious she was staying over Belle Amie because she had stayed out of it since week 1, whereas they were there in week 2 so probably had less support by week 4. I think Katie would have had more votes than Treyc tonight anyway but I think it would have been fairer to take it to deadlock to find out for sure. I wouldn't be surprised if they got a heap of complaints about tonight's results.

I disagree! They would save almost all the remaining acts except Wagner maybe.

TreyC is just too forgettable and they were right to get rid tbh. She brings little to the show whereas Katie brings headlines at least.

but it was katies third time plus she forgot the words and said sod it.

True, I cant imagine Belle Amie will have been particularly popular either, Katie has a lot of haters but she does have a fair few fans as well.

I think most complaints will be over the whole farce concerning Cheryl's vote. Firstly she shouldnt have been allowed to cop-out like she did, and then Dermot kinda ignored her at the end there when she said let her go last.