Katharine McPhee
 

I know she's on Idol, but I think she's that good she deserves her own topic.:tongue:

Any fans out there?

I want her to win now!

She'd get my vote out of the final 3! :thumbs:

"Black Horse and the Cherry Tree" was great! :bigsmile:

I also loved her version, Tom.

She really put her stamp on it.:spin2:

Sadly, although I'd rather Taylor went, I have a feeling she'll be out this week! :sad:

.... I really should stay more positive, eh!? :spin:

Hmm.. I really don't like Taylor. He just looks like a drunken grandad who shouts his way through every song.:puzzled:

I'm still reeling from Kellie Pickler being kicked off. -___-;;

Agree completely! :thumbs:

Sorry to disagree with you, Zi, but I wasn't such a fan of Kellie - her voice had begun to grate on me a tad! :blush2:

I hope Kat wins now shes the only decent 1 left x

Too inconsistent for me.

Quite agree BB Frenzy - thought last week she deserved to go.

Zi, I have to disagree. Kellie was sweet but just average and nothing more, IMO. She wasn't better than any of the people that outlasted her.

I don't think Katharine is inconsistant btw. She has had a less than lacklustre performances but so does everyone on these shows. Just my opinion. But, for me, she's great and I hope she wins.:thumbs:

I want Katherine to win, she is the only one which will sell over the years and last. I think Taylor is popular BUT he will only sell a certain amount then people will tire of him. I really wanted Chris to win the whole thing but im going for kat now:bigsmile:

Kellie was my favourite too Zi. Katherine to win now though yeah, great voice.

Kelly annoyed me her talking voice was awful, so was Paris's talking voice.

Katharine is miles better than Taylor. I still don't know what on earth he doing in the final. He looks like he's in pain when he sings.

Kat's version of SOTR this week was fab. Loved it!:wink: