Sugababes showdown
 

Which line up of the Sugababes had the best debut single? I'm bored and I like music, go figure.

1.0 - Overload



2.0 - Freak Like Me



3.0 - About You Now



4.0 - Freedom




N.B. I count "debut" as the first song off a fresh album project with each new line up, e.g. Amelle and Jade came into the band mid way through an album campaign so it wasn't "their" material. I don't count Easy or Walk This Way as being Amelle's debut because Easy was with the greatest hits and Walk This Way was a charity single.

2.0 > 1.0 > 3.0 > 4.0

OMFG TOUGHY

about you now > freak like me > freedom > overload

all amazing songs though

freak like me /freedom/overload/about you now / all good though :D !!

ha2 at you suggesting Freedom is 'music'.

Freak Like Me, even if it's basically a mashup :tongue: Overload second.

Freak Like Me> Overload> Chlymidia> The rest.

Overload > Freak Like Me > Freedom > About You Now (hate that song sf much)

But actual lineup overall:

2 > 3 > 1 > 4

Line up overall 2 > 4 > 3 > 1

I love all those songs muchly(hell, I love all Sugababes songs, period) but Ive voted About you now.

It's such a great pop song and opened them up to a wider audience. Not so moody urban cool anymore.

4 weeks at No.1 :worship:

tbh we haven't even heard the full version of Freedom yet or video

Freak Like Me :love: :love:

2>1>3>4

isn't about a girl also 4.0s 1st single?

2 :love:

Freak Like Me > Overload > Freedom > About You Now

Lineup overall
2 > 3 > 4 > 1

Just voted Freak Like Me and it came on the music channels :suspect:

How about you vote Cher next :suspect:

Freak like me has the most Gary Numan in it. So that.

I think I'm developing a crush on Heidi Range too. She's very hot in a very domestic way. Like someone plucked her straight from watching the soaps and said 'you're going to be a popstar, love!'.



:amazed:

Sky 362 right now :suspect:

As with Amelle joining mid way through an album campaign, I'm not counting Keisha's leftover material as 4.0's first single.

WTF is with the hate for About You Now?

it's so bland. If you reduce it to the melody it's just so dull. And there's nothing interesting in the rhythm or beat either - it's something that Atomic Kitten could've done, whereas 'Overload' was different.