Week 3 Ratings
 

No thread? :puzzled:


Marcus - I really didn’t expect him to be so good. Fantastic show opener. Set a standard for the rest of the night that nobody surpassed -- 8/10
Janet - Liking her new found feistiness but I can’t help feeling it‘s a little bit forced and unnatural. Good vocals nonetheless -- 6/10
Sami - Another horrific song choice. She didn’t look happy singing it and I think her vocals suffered because of it. Cringe-worthy desperation in the interview afterwards too -- 3/10
Rhythmix- Rock week? Horrible vocals, uninteresting performance and a really stupid melody. Bottom two worthy -- 2/10
Sophie - Up and down. Sounded great in parts, uncomfortable in others -- 5/10
Craig - His curling upper lip distracted me from the otherwise decent vocals - 4/10
Kitty - A little bit clunky at times but vocally brilliant -- 8/10
Frankie - I’m glad they didn’t so down the usual ‘feeling sorry for self’ route with the VT, but the whole rockstar act was so overplayed. Just shows what a terrible, out-of-touch mentor Gary Barlow is. I completely agree with Tulisa; he’s lost the cheeky chappy attitude that we all saw in auditions. His best performance to date but that’s hardly saying much -- 3/10
The Risk - Rock week? Nice albeit slightly boring performance -- 5/10
Johnny - Even his serious performances are jokey. Likeable guy but he doesn’t deserve to stay over most other acts -- 2/10
Misha - Obvious song choice that’s been done to death. Brilliant vocals but she’s starting to come across as a bit of an ice queen - which is why I wasn’t really surprised with Tulisa and Louis‘ comments. Needs to show a bit of a softer side if she wants to go as far as she should -- 7/10

if you think that marcus was good then the thread has ended

Marcus - Hhmmhmm that boy can sing 7/10
Janet - i forgot about her performance again, but this time it was like a bit boring (the voice was good though) -- 4/10
Sami - she looked a tad off it ( a bottom 2 most likely)-- 3/10
Rhythmix- Please Tulisa dont get pissy about Kelly song choice, as this song choice was horried ( would of been good for 2 shoes thouhg :) ) -- 5/10
Sophie - Eeeekk, lets hope your still here next week, good luck! -- 5/10
Craig - one of the best - 8/10
Kitty - "i can get set on fire" a comment like that deserves an 8 -- 8/10
Frankie - the opening was horried, the voice horrid just leave Frankie..how girls like him when it showed him getting of with numerous girls is crazy (Bottom 2 material) -- 2/10
The Risk - they all looked out of it. but good vocals-- 6/10
Johnny - it was like an advert.. -- 4/10
Misha - Misha B...You put it down, i found it incredibly selfish of what Tulisa said, it was like she was getting back at Kelly for her putting down her song choices, and if it happened back stage it should of been said backstage-- 8/10

Easily in the top 4 last night...

Travesty if he end's up in the B2.

he is 3rd bottom with the bookies (Frankie and fatty are bottom 2)


make of that what you will

Best of the night and one of only three acts that fully embraced the rock theme I reckon. Care to explain why you think he was bad or are you just going to claim unjust superiority?

Marcus. Lively performance but little else to write home about. 6/10.
Janet. Good song choice and liked the way she did it. 8/10
Sami. I like this song, I quite like Sami too, Gary too harsh. 6/10
Rythmix. Was okay, not mad about them at all though. 5/10
Sophie. Murdered the 'Calling' song last week. Not much better.4/10
Craig. Really good voice, did really good. 8/10
Kitty. Great peformance. Liked it a lot. 9/10
Frankie. Just don't get him I'm afraid, A poor choice by Gary. 3/10
Risk. They are growing on me a lot. 5/10
Johnny. Perfect song for him. he was really good.Being fair. 7/10
Misha. Not impressed. Not a singer I am likely to like. 4/10

His voice is tinny. he has zero charisma. he looks like a pixie. his rock effort was unconvincing.

Marcus. It was Ok.. 6/10.
Janet. Good song choice, wish she sung a dancy track, like rebecca did with 'show me love' last year! 7/10
Sammi should do an upbeat modern song :/ 5/10
Rythmix. ok... 8/10
Sophie. AMAZING. 8/10
Craig. gooood!. 8/10
Kitty. Just fantastic. 10/10
Frankie. i find him really sleazy, and i feel he doesn't belong on this show, rancid little turd. 1/10
THE Risk. Crazy;). 8/10
Johnny. My guilty pleasure. 8/10
Misha. She's a bully and a diva. nuff said. 4/10

listen to lennys original and you will see how bad marcus rendition was

Now that wasn't so hard, was it? :blush:

So we're judging them on how similar they sound to the original song now? I must have missed the memo.

You obviously only hate him because he's gay.

No, it is because he is crap, one dimensional and has no charisma

I dislike Craig because of his hair and the fact he thinks he is Aretha Franklin. I dislike Misha B because she has the personality of a hoover bag.

I also dislike Derry from Risk as he is a t wat

Its more to do with who they are than where they want to insert their penis

You still hate gay people.