Louis Walsh unsure on XF return next year
 

Video here: http://www.mydaily.co.uk/2011/11/11/...h-louis-walsh/

I really miss Dannii on the X Factor panel. :(

Personally I think the whole show needs resting for a bit - it's got very tired.

I'll never be happy unless its Simon, Sharon and Louis :(

Its not been a good one this year nobody stands out.

Even though a lot of people really hated it last year, my favourite panel is Dannii, Simon, Cheryl and Louis, I've really missed Dannii this year :(

Let's hope he stays next year and we get a line-up of Danni, Tulisa, Louis and Simon.

:worship:

The whole show is going down the sh**ter anyway

He wants a Simon-Sharon-Danni-Louis panel :worship:

Yeah because that really worked the first time

Theyll probably get someone from the Wanted in to continue their ''lets get judges from crap pop groups'' tradition along with Tulisa

I don't care, that was still the best year panel-wise. I loved how bitchy it was :joker:

As long as Cheryl bloody Cole is nowhere near that pannel desk then im happy.

..but I still want Simon, Sharon & Louis :suspect:

Probably, or wouldn't surprise me if someone from One Direction or Olly Murs joined the panel to offer their expertise

Chris Moyles is the only person that can replace Louis

doogle series 4 was awful :nono:

The finalists were **** but it had the best auditions and that crazy bitch Emily who happy slapped someone and the best panel

Series 4 panel was terrible, Dannii completely ruined the Simon Louis and Sharon dynamic without actually adding anything

Dannii couldn't have been any further up Simon's arse that year either, even worse than Cheryl but everyone seems to forget about that because Louis made her cry on air the year after

I just cannot get into the series this year at all, I am still watching it but Gary gets on my nerves and I find him far too full of himself, Kelly drives me mad, she is way over the top.

I don't like this bringing an act back,Kelly's hypocrisy knows no bounds, she praised Amelia to the heavens tonight but at the first opportunity sent her packing in the very first show.

No wonder Louis is fed up, this series has become a farce and whoever wins is likely to have the shortest career ever because there is little credibility left from the bit that was left until now.

Gary and Kelly particularly have been a huge mistake on the show. It's fading definately.

It'll be a travesty if Louis leaves, it didn't work for one episode during series four and it certainly wouldn't work for an entire series. He's not disposable like Dannii/Cheryl etc and as stupid as his comments/choices may often be, it brings an entirely different dimension to the panel if you ask me, and they'd struggle to find a suitable replacement, I agree with Tom regarding Chris Moyles though. But you can't top Louis, he's just...lovable, in an annoying way.

It didn't work because they put Brian in as his replacement, who is so dull it's unreal. Louis is completely disposable, his only purpose is to irritate the other judges and be lumped with the crap category every year. I've never liked Louis all that much, but this year I just don't hate him as much because Gary and Kelly are worse.

I think Louis leaving would kill the show.

x factor just isnt the same any more..

That's the entertainment in it though, if we didn't have that the panel would be way too serious, a lot less funny and there wouldn't really be any 'stupid' judge for everyone to laugh at.

You could argue of course that the panel needs to be more serious, but let's face it, it's all panto...you need that element of humour.

The role that he fills is entertaining, yes, but I don't think he himself is entertaining. There are plenty of people who could take on that role and do it better than Louis. The show needs him this year because he's experienced in the role, but if Simon, Cheryl and Dannii were still there and somebody else had replaced Louis, I really doubt anyone would have missed his presence on the show. It's panto but it doesn't have to be stupid.

I have to disagree, I think Louis is one of a kind if you ask me. Yeah there are other people like Chris Moyles who would fulfill the role well and would be entertaining, but I really don't think anybody could top Louis. Louis is just...Louis.